Nestled in the heart of Bismarck at 820 43rd Avenue Northeast, New York To Go offers a genuine slice of the Big Apple right in North Dakota. Specializing in classic New York-style pizza, calzones, gyros, wings, and Nathan's hot dogs, this spot is perfect for food lovers craving authentic flavors. Whether you dine in or opt for delivery or takeout, you’ll enjoy a menu crafted with quality ingredients and New York flair.
Locals rave about the perfectly crisp, yet tender New York pizza crust that stays true to its roots. You’ll find toppings like fresh mushrooms — never canned — and a balanced San Marzano-based sauce that adds a subtle sweetness. The friendly staff and clean, inviting space enhance your dining experience, whether you’re grabbing lunch or a casual dinner. Plus, their rewards program lets you earn points on your orders, making every visit more rewarding.
While many patrons praise New York To Go for its authentic flavors and excellent service, some have noted that the prices are on the higher side compared to other local options. A few customers have experienced inconsistencies in food quality, especially with takeout orders, so checking your order before leaving is a good idea. Overall, the restaurant maintains a solid reputation for delivering a true New York pizza experience in Bismarck.
- Dine-in, takeout, and delivery available to suit your schedule and mood.
- Free parking on-site and street parking make visits hassle-free.
- Multiple payment options including NFC mobile payments, credit, and debit cards.
- What are the restaurant's hours of operation? Monday to Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM; Sunday: 11:30 AM – 7:30 PM.
- Does New York To Go offer delivery? Yes, they offer delivery, takeout, and dine-in options.
- What are the daily specials? Daily specials include specific large pizzas and wing deals throughout the week, such as Monday's 14" Pepperoni and Friday's 20" Bronx Pizza.
- Is there parking available? Yes, there is free parking available.
- Does the restaurant accept credit cards? Yes, they accept credit and debit cards, as well as NFC mobile payments.
Founded in 2019 by a passionate local couple from North Dakota, New York To Go was born out of a memorable trip to New York City in 2012. Inspired by a legendary pizzeria there, they set out to bring the unmistakable flavor and texture of classic New York-style pizza to the heart of Bismarck. Their dedication to authenticity is evident in their use of the innovative NY Watermaker™ system, which replicates the mineral composition of New York City water — a key secret to the unique dough that New Yorkers rave about.
Since opening its doors in 2019, New York To Go has quickly become a beloved spot for pizza aficionados and casual diners alike. The founders’ commitment to replicating the New York pizza experience meant carefully crafting dough with their patented water system, resulting in a crust that’s both crisp and chewy, reminiscent of the Big Apple’s iconic slices. Alongside pizza, the menu has expanded to include gyros, Nathan's hot dogs, calzones, and wings, satisfying a wide range of cravings for locals and visitors.
When the COVID-19 pandemic struck in 2020, New York To Go swiftly pivoted to prioritize takeout and delivery services, ensuring that their loyal customers could still enjoy authentic New York flavors safely from home. This adaptability not only helped the business weather the storm but also deepened its connection with the community. By 2021, their dedication to quality and authenticity earned wider recognition, solidifying their reputation as the go-to destination for genuine New York-style pizza in Bismarck.
- Authentic New York-style pizza dough made with the NY Watermaker™ replicating NYC water for perfect crust texture and flavor.
- Menu diversity featuring not only pizza but also gyros, Nathan's hot dogs, calzones, and wings to please every palate.
- Community focus and resilience demonstrated by their quick adaptation to takeout and delivery during the pandemic, keeping the authentic New York experience alive in Bismarck.
Nestled in Bismarck, North Dakota, New York To Go offers a slice of the Big Apple with its authentic New York-style pizza and gyros. Situated at 820 43rd Ave NE, this eatery promises a culinary experience that delights both locals and visitors. With an inviting atmosphere and a focus on quality ingredients, it has become a go-to spot for those craving flavorful pizza, whether for dining in or taking out.
- Authentic New York-style pizza and gyros
- Friendly and efficient staff
- Offers delivery and pickup options
- Daily and lunch specials available
- Gluten-free crust option
- Limited seating with bar stools
- Focus on takeout and delivery
- Some customers mention limited seating
New York To Go is perfect for pizza lovers looking for a quick meal or a satisfying takeout option. It caters to families craving a casual dining experience, as well as students and young professionals seeking a delicious lunch or dinner on-the-go. The rewards program, which offers discounts and points for future purchases, makes it an appealing choice for frequent visitors.
Visitors should note that New York To Go has limited seating, primarily with bar stools, making it better suited for quick visits or takeout. The restaurant offers both delivery and pickup options, ensuring convenience for those on the move. Guests can enjoy daily specials and a gluten-free crust option, catering to diverse dietary needs.
In summary, New York To Go stands out for its authentic pizza offerings and friendly service. While the limited seating might be a drawback for some, its focus on takeout and delivery ensures it remains a popular choice in Bismarck. The daily specials and loyalty rewards provide added value, making it an excellent spot for pizza enthusiasts looking for a quick yet satisfying meal.
- What are the operating hours?
- Do they offer vegetarian options?
- Is there parking available?
Experience the taste of New York right in Bismarck by visiting New York To Go. With its robust flavors and welcoming atmosphere, it's the perfect destination for pizza enthusiasts and anyone craving a quick, delicious meal.
Nestled in the heart of Bismarck at 820 43rd Ave NE #124, New York To Go is a must-visit for pizza lovers and foodies craving authentic New York style slices with a modern twist. This gem offers a refined take on pizza that stands out in North Dakota's dining scene, boasting a crust that’s perfectly crisp and deliciously thin — not your typical puffy fast food variety. Guests rave about their pepperoni pizzas, available in sizes ranging from a personal 10 inch to a generously large pie, making it ideal for solo foodies or sharing with friends.
Whether you prefer to savor your pizza right on the spot with limited dine-in seating, or enjoy the convenience of ordering online for quick takeaway, New York To Go covers all bases. Their no-contact delivery is perfect for busy digital nomads or families wanting fresh, hot pizza without stepping out. Plus, the seamless online ordering and efficient service make it a breeze to get your favorite dishes delivered or ready for pickup.
New York To Go’s commitment to quality shines through every bite. They use a San Marzano based sauce known for its sweet, balanced flavor and a texture that complements the crisp crust. Reviews highlight the fresh toppings, especially mushrooms, which bring a natural earthiness unmatched by canned alternatives. While some find the cheese blend interestingly different from the classic mozzarella, this uniqueness contributes to their signature style. Plus, their premium pricing reflects the top-tier ingredients and artisan preparation methods.
- Reward program benefits: Earn points with every order and redeem discounts on future visits.
- Friendly staff: Known for welcoming service that makes every visit enjoyable.
- Parking convenience: Free parking lot and street parking options make access hassle-free.
New York To Go is carving a niche for itself in Bismarck’s food scene, offering a New York pizza experience that balances tradition with fresh innovation. Whether you’re local or just passing through, treat yourself to a slice that’s become a beloved favorite among residents. Remember to double-check your order when picking up to avoid any hiccups, and then sit back and enjoy some of the best pizza the city has to offer.
