Nestled in the vibrant South Central neighborhood of Salem, Oregon, Straight from New York Pizza brings a slice of the Big Apple right to Commercial Street Southeast. This trendy counter-serve pizza parlor is beloved for its handcrafted pies, generous slices, and satisfyingly stuffed calzones, all served alongside a curated selection of local beers. Whether you're a dedicated foodie, a digital nomad craving a casual lunch spot, or simply in town for delicious pizza, this spot delivers an inviting atmosphere with a flavor-packed experience.
Straight from New York Pizza prides itself on classic New York-style pizza, featuring thin, crispy crusts with just the right balance of sauce and cheese. Popular options include the fan-favorite Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza, praised for its juicy, flavorful toppings, and the perfectly thick yet soft calzone, ideal for sharing. Vegetarian pizza lovers can rejoice with delicious meat-free options, and those with dietary restrictions will appreciate the availability of gluten-free crusts in 14-inch sizes.
The casual, lively ambiance is enhanced by outdoor seating, perfect for soaking up Salem's mild weather while enjoying a slice. Customers frequently commend the friendly service and the welcoming vibe, making it an excellent spot for families with children or groups of friends looking to unwind over great food and craft beer.
While the pizza consistently receives high praise for authenticity and taste, some guests note that extras like wings and salads occasionally fall short of expectations, so sticking to the pizza-centric menu might enhance your experience. Parking can be a bit challenging due to limited spaces and a reliance on street parking, so arriving early or using alternative transport methods is advisable. The restaurant accommodates dine-in, takeout, and delivery, offering flexibility whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a relaxed evening out.
- What are the operating hours of Straight from New York Pizza? The restaurant operates Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM, Friday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, Saturday from 12:00 PM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 7:00 PM.
- Is there parking available at the restaurant? Parking is limited, and customers often need to find street parking, which can be a bit challenging.
- Do they offer gluten-free options? Yes, they offer gluten-free crust available in 14-inch size.
- Is the restaurant pet-friendly? The restaurant has outdoor seating, but it's unclear if pets are allowed. It's advisable to contact the restaurant directly for confirmation.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, they offer delivery, takeout, and dine-in options.
Established in 1986, Straight from New York Pizza brought an authentic taste of the Big Apple to Oregon, starting with its very first location in downtown Salem. This pizzeria quickly became a local favorite for those craving the iconic aroma and flavor of true New York-style pizza, characterized by its wide, thin crust and vibrant sauce.
A decade after opening its doors, Straight from New York Pizza expanded its influence by launching a second location in Salem in 1996. This growth signaled the brand’s increasing popularity among Oregon residents seeking a genuine New York pizza experience. The momentum continued with a bold step into Portland in 2006, opening a third location that brought their celebrated pies to a larger metropolitan audience.
By 2018, the pizzeria had cemented its place in Portland with three bustling spots on Belmont Street, West Burnside Street, and Hawthorne Boulevard. Each location offers the same handcrafted pies, slices, and calzones that have become a hallmark of their brand, complemented by a trendy counter-serve atmosphere and a curated selection of beers to enjoy. The commitment to authentic New York-style pizza has never wavered, attracting both longtime fans and newcomers.
- 1986: First location opened in downtown Salem, Oregon.
- 1996: Second location opened in Salem to meet growing demand.
- 2006: Third location opened in Portland, expanding their Oregon footprint.
- 2018: Three Portland locations thriving on Belmont Street, West Burnside Street, and Hawthorne Boulevard.
- 2025: Continues to serve authentic New York-style pizza across Oregon with a loyal following.
Today, Straight from New York Pizza remains a staple in Oregon’s vibrant culinary scene. Their dedication to maintaining the authentic flavors and textures of New York pizza has earned them a dedicated community of food lovers, families, and pizza enthusiasts. Whether grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a handcrafted calzone paired with a local beer, visitors can experience a genuine taste of New York right in the Pacific Northwest.
Located at 2918 Commercial St SE, Salem, OR, Straight from New York Pizza offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza. This trendy counter-serve establishment specializes in handcrafted pies, slices, and calzones, complemented by a selection of beers. Ideal for pizza lovers, it has garnered attention for its generous toppings and friendly service.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Generous toppings
- Friendly service
- Gluten-free options available
- Outdoor seating available
- Inconsistent cleanliness
- Limited parking
- Service consistency issues
Straight from New York Pizza is perfect for casual family meals, quick lunch breaks, or gatherings with friends. Its inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for pizza lovers of all ages.
Be prepared for a bustling environment, especially during peak hours. While the pizza is highly recommended, some side dishes may not meet expectations. Parking can be limited, so consider arriving early or using nearby street parking.
Straight from New York Pizza delivers a solid pizza experience with its authentic flavors and friendly service. While there are some inconsistencies in side dishes and service, the main attraction—the pizza—remains a crowd-pleaser. For those in Salem seeking a taste of New York, this spot is worth a visit.
If you're in Salem, Oregon, and craving a slice of the Big Apple, Straight from New York Pizza is your go-to spot on Commercial Street Southeast. This trendy counter-serve pizzeria brings the unmistakable flavor of New York-style pies right to the heart of Marion County with an emphasis on quality, authenticity, and a casual yet inviting atmosphere.
Straight from New York Pizza crafts each pie by hand, using the finest ingredients to create classic New York-style pizzas with thin, foldable crusts and rich sauce and cheese combinations. Beyond pizza, their menu features delicious calzones packed with flavorful fillings, fresh salads topped with a variety of crisp ingredients, and crispy chicken wings offered in BBQ, Buffalo, or Plain styles. For those with dietary needs, a gluten-free 14-inch crust option ensures everyone can enjoy authentic pizza.
Complement your meal with a refreshing selection of sodas or choose from SFNY beer served in generous 64oz growlers, perfect for sharing with friends or family. The spot features dine-in with outdoor seating, making it a great place to enjoy lunch or dinner in a lively yet laid-back setting. They also offer takeout and delivery, catering to your convenience whether dining in or at home.
Known for its authentic New York vibe, Straight from New York Pizza has become a beloved spot for locals and visitors craving that classic pizza experience. The friendly and generous customer service adds warmth to the culinary experience, while convenient free parking options and multiple payment methods make visits hassle-free. Families with children will appreciate the kid-friendly environment and variety of menu choices to suit all tastes.
- Handcrafted Pies - Authentic New York-style pizzas made with the finest ingredients.
- Calzones - Delicious calzones filled with a variety of toppings.
- Wings - Crispy chicken wings available in BBQ, Buffalo, or Plain flavors.
- Gluten-Free Options - Gluten-free crust available in 14-inch size.
Whether you're a local Salemite or a traveler seeking an authentic slice of New York, this pizzeria offers a vibrant, laid-back dining experience with options for every appetite, including vegetarian and gluten-free dishes. Enjoy your meal with a cold beer or soda on their outdoor patio or grab a slice to go. With friendly service, a family-friendly environment, and a menu that honors classic recipes while accommodating modern preferences, Straight from New York Pizza is a must-try destination for pizza lovers in Oregon.
