Nestled in the vibrant Squirrel Hill South neighborhood of Pittsburgh, New York Super Subs offers an authentic taste of New York-style sandwiches that food lovers and locals rave about. Known for its generous portions and a menu bursting with classic deli favorites, this spot is a must-visit for anyone craving a hearty, satisfying sub with a true urban twist.
At New York Super Subs, each sandwich showcases high-quality meats and freshly baked bread, which customers frequently highlight as standout features. Popular choices include the iconic House Super Special and the savory Cheesesteak Sub, available in one-foot or two-foot sizes for those with a big appetite. Vegetarians will appreciate the thoughtfully crafted Veggie Sub options that cater to plant-based diets without compromising flavor.
Bakery and Desserts complement the savory menu with an in-house bakery offering cannolis, eclairs, cookies, and brownies. While the cannoli shells may vary in crispness, the filling tends to impress with its creamy texture, providing a sweet finale to your meal.
The atmosphere at New York Super Subs is casual and friendly, with an emphasis on quick service and quality. The cozy space features outdoor seating, making it an inviting spot for lunch or dinner in the heart of Pittsburgh. Visitors often note the attentive staff and authentic New York deli feel, which adds to the overall satisfying experience despite a few minor inconsistencies during busy hours.
- Freshly baked bread and quality meats are the stars of the menu. Iconic sandwiches like the House Super Special and Cheesesteak are crowd favorites.
- In-house bakery offers cannolis, eclairs, and other sweet treats. While dessert quality may vary, they complement the savory menu nicely.
- Friendly, quick service with outdoor seating available. Perfect for a casual lunch or dinner in Pittsburgh’s Squirrel Hill.
- What are the restaurant's operating hours? Monday to Saturday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Sunday: Closed.
- Does New York Super Subs offer delivery? Yes, they offer delivery services through platforms like Uber Eats and Postmates.
- Is there parking available at the restaurant? Yes, parking is available near the restaurant.
- Does the restaurant have a bakery? Yes, they have an in-house bakery offering fresh baked goods.
- Are there vegetarian options on the menu? Yes, the menu includes vegetarian-friendly options like the Veggie Sub.
The overall community sentiment about New York Super Subs is positive. Locals appreciate the restaurant's commitment to quality, especially in their hearty sandwiches and friendly service. While some reviews mention minor inconsistencies with dessert quality and occasional order mix-ups, these do not overshadow the establishment's reputation as a reliable spot for New York-style subs in Pittsburgh's Allegheny County.
Whether you’re a foodie seeking authentic New York flavors or a local looking for a satisfying meal with generous portions, New York Super Subs in Squirrel Hill South offers a flavorful experience that’s worth a visit.
Nestled in the vibrant heart of Pittsburgh's Squirrel Hill South neighborhood, New York Super Subs has carved out a niche for itself since opening in 2015. This sandwich shop brings the authentic flavors of New York-style subs to Pennsylvania, delighting locals and visitors alike with its dedication to quality and tradition.
After establishing a strong foothold with its classic New York subs, the restaurant expanded its offerings in 2017 to include an in-house bakery. This addition brought fresh baked goods like cannolis, eclairs, and cookies, complementing the sandwich menu and offering a true deli experience reminiscent of New York's iconic eateries.
Responding to changing customer preferences, New York Super Subs began offering delivery services in 2020 through popular platforms such as Uber Eats and Postmates. This move enhanced accessibility, allowing fans of their hearty sandwiches and baked goods to enjoy their favorites from the comfort of home.
Celebrating over eight years in the Squirrel Hill community by 2023, New York Super Subs continues to offer a blend of traditional New York deli flavors and local charm. Known for friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, it remains a go-to spot for substantial sandwiches like the classic Reuben and cheesesteak subs, alongside a selection of vegetarian options and freshly baked treats.
- 2015 New York Super Subs opened its first location in Pittsburgh's Squirrel Hill neighborhood.
- 2017 The restaurant expanded its menu to include an in-house bakery offering fresh baked goods.
- 2020 New York Super Subs began offering delivery services through platforms like Uber Eats and Postmates.
- 2023 The restaurant celebrated its 8th anniversary in the Squirrel Hill location.
Located at 1827 Murray Ave in Pittsburgh's Squirrel Hill South neighborhood, New York Super Subs offers a taste of classic New York-style sandwiches. Known for its generous portions and house-made ingredients, this eatery has become a local favorite for those craving hearty subs and delectable desserts. With outdoor seating available, it provides a casual dining experience perfect for lunch or dinner.
The restaurant prides itself on its variety of subs, including the classic Reuben and cheesesteak, alongside a selection of desserts like cannolis and eclairs. While the atmosphere is casual, the focus remains on delivering quality food that satisfies.
• Generous portion sizes
• Fresh, house-made ingredients
• Friendly and attentive service
• Variety of subs and desserts
• Outdoor seating available
• Higher prices compared to some competitors
• Limited seating inside
• No Sunday service
• Casual lunch breaks
• Family dinners
• Takeout for picnics or gatherings
• Takeout and delivery options are available
• Outdoor seating is a plus during warmer months
• Payment options include credit and debit cards
• No restroom facilities on-site
New York Super Subs offers a solid option for those craving hearty sandwiches in Pittsburgh. While it may not rival the iconic delis of New York, it delivers a satisfying experience with its generous portions and friendly service. However, potential visitors should be aware of its higher prices and limited seating. Overall, it's a worthwhile stop for sandwich lovers.
