Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

London, England

Red Room

Copenhagen, Denmark

Delphine

Amsterdam, Netherlands

Chez Nina Green Brasserie

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Guide to

During Winter

Prague 

in Finland

The Northern Lights

Winter Edition

Paris

Best bars

New York Cities

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

On A Budget

5 Star Luxury Travel

You Must Visit

Eco-Friendly Hotels

Avoid Bali belly

How To:

That Are Worth The Trip

Dining Concepts

The World Is Slowing Down

Soft Travel

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Explore

Copenhagens Boutique Hotels

Discover

Tokyos best Ramen

Travel philosophy

The Rise of ‘Soft Travel’

Dublin Best Pubs

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Madison, WI

North America

United States

# Overview
The Stuffed Olive is a vibrant restaurant located at 351 State St, Madison, WI. Known for its extensive martini menu and cozy atmosphere, it serves as a popular spot for both locals and visitors. The restaurant offers a unique blend of tapas and flatbreads, making it an ideal destination for casual dining or special occasions. With a focus on quality service and a welcoming environment, The Stuffed Olive has carved out a niche in Madison's culinary scene, attracting those looking to enjoy creative cocktails and delicious food.

## History
The Stuffed Olive has become a staple in Madison's dining landscape, evolving from a small local eatery to a well-known destination for food and drink enthusiasts. Over the years, it has celebrated numerous milestones, including the introduction of its signature martini menu, which features a wide array of flavors. The restaurant has influenced the local culture by promoting a social dining experience, where sharing plates and drinks fosters community interaction. The evolution of its menu reflects changing culinary trends, while traditions such as themed drink nights keep patrons engaged and returning.

## Community
The Stuffed Olive actively engages with the Madison community through various partnerships and events. Collaborations with local farms ensure fresh ingredients, supporting sustainability and local agriculture. The restaurant hosts events that bring people together, such as martini tastings and themed nights, fostering a sense of community. Voices from the community often highlight the restaurant's role as a gathering place, where friends and families can enjoy good food and drinks in a relaxed setting. Connecting with local artists and musicians also enhances the dining experience, making it a cultural hub in Madison.

## Offerings
At The Stuffed Olive, patrons can expect a diverse menu that includes tapas, salads, and an extensive selection of martinis. The restaurant offers customizable dining experiences, allowing guests to create their own combinations of small plates and drinks. Signature items include various flatbreads and unique appetizers, making it a great spot for sharing. The ambiance is perfect for casual gatherings, date nights, or special occasions, with options for private events available. Guests are encouraged to explore the creative drink menu, which features both classic and innovative cocktails.

## Pros and Cons
Review insights reveal a mix of experiences at The Stuffed Olive. Strengths include a creative martini menu, attentive staff, and a cozy atmosphere, making it a favored spot for many. However, some weaknesses have been noted, such as inconsistent service during busy times and occasional issues with food timing. Overall, the restaurant is praised for its vibrant ambiance and quality food, though some patrons suggest improvements in training staff to enhance the dining experience.

## Location & Nearby
Located in the heart of Madison, The Stuffed Olive is easily accessible and surrounded by a vibrant neighborhood filled with cultural attractions. The address at 351 State St places it within walking distance of several local landmarks, including theaters, shops, and parks. This central location makes it an ideal stop for those exploring the city, providing a convenient dining option after a day of sightseeing or shopping.

## Visit The Stuffed Olive Today
With its unique offerings, rich history, and strong community ties, The Stuffed Olive invites you to experience what makes it a beloved restaurant in Madison. Whether you're looking to enjoy a creative martini, share delicious tapas, or simply soak in the cozy atmosphere, this restaurant has something for everyone. Join the community of satisfied patrons and discover why The Stuffed Olive is a must-visit destination in Madison.

5e490e95-aec4-446e-9f81-a6929a571ae7

The martinis here are always fantastic. The staff does well even on busy nights. Special shoutouts to the bartenders who are always extra attentive and absolutely hilarious; Kali, James and Ashlyn.

4fc71a9a-2191-48dc-b877-c60572ab4f22

Amazing food and drinks!!! Even better service. 10/10 spot for me! The hangover burger is one of the best burgers I've ever had! Very clean and relaxing place to go out too!

ae7d2c6d-427b-4a00-83a4-7ccecd7a5cee

The Stuffed Olive has ENDLESS flavors of martinis!!! Some of the flavors were a bit strange, like mashed potato or birthday cake. They all seem very interesting! I can't wait to come back and try more. We ordered the spinach artichoke flatbread which was super salty, but that wasn't a problem for me since I love a good salty snack paired with a super sugary drink! This place is suuuper cute and it's right next to I/O the arcade bar. Loved the vibes and had a great time. Thanks!

d5eac2f1-d2c5-4f1f-9e5d-e5c13c0dccbe

Not sure how this place is in business. Our poor waiter obviously was not trained well. It was a goat rodeo of an experience. Items ordered never coming to the table. Main plates arriving before appetizers. For one of our parties the appetizer came with the main plate. Waiter couldn't manage to find our bill on his remote checkout appliance and had a small breakdown so the other waiter had to bail him out and finish the transaction after 5 minutes of him sitting against the wall by our table just udderly confused. We would of liked to have seen the bill to see if it was correct since we didn't receive some of our appetizers but thought that would of just pushed him over the edge..some patrons left as they never got any service after waiting over 30 minutes and not being addressed. It wasn't a full house.. Now why the generous 2 stars you ask? Well, my food tasted solid. I had the caprese flatbread and it was good but definitely could be better had they used fresh tomatoes especially this time of year and them being 2 blocks from the Dane County farmers market. I also had the hummus and it was good and the donuts for dessert were decent. One of my parties had the tuna and he said it could have been more flavorful but it was ok. He also said the bruschetta was solid. My husband had the whiskey sliders and he said they were good (juicy) and would probably order again. The last in our party had a pesto chicken flatbread and she said it was pretty good but needed more pesto. We were supposed to have the olive appetizer but it never came so can't speak to those. Our other appetizer, the spinach dip came after we had our meal. He had forgotten about it and when he brought it out you could tell it had been sitting a while. I think it would be good freshly baked. As for drinks, one had a dirty bird and it was way too dirty... need to lighten that up a bit. 2 had mocktails and they were fine (lemonade based) and the last had the Rose that was on special and it was solid. Womens restroom was not clean.. yuk! We obviously are not returning. I can't imagine they will be around long if they don't make changes. We truly felt bad for our server. Not trained well and where is the manager to help support him when he needs it? Or the owner?

6511de69-d6e3-4455-8402-178596baa3f6

This is the absolute cutest and coziest little Restaurant. The ambience makes it perfect for date night, girls night, brunch or any sort of get together. The way the seating is set up, you even feel comfortable going to eat alone. The food was fresh and hot when he came out. The sliders with the caramelized onions was so tender and juicy. I didn't get the ghost pepper cheese because I knew it was going to be too hot for me. Also, the Thai chicken flatbread was enough for two people to share. The martinis oh my goodness the martinis!! From the picture you can tell that we were there in the daytime and we had to stop ourselves at one each. They were so good. This is a spot that we would definitely go back to. We totally enjoyed it & Staff was fantastic.

e9b21f97-0fb1-4b89-8d0d-e55a4be5d74b

Stuffed Olive has a hotel ambiance, the seats, lighting, and decor all feel comfortable corporate. There is typically available seating and the servers are quick to get to you. After you order your drinks you may need to wave them down if you are wanting more. The food is good but definitely a little over priced considering the size. There are a TON of martini options to choose from and very creative additions you can add. Plan on walking as it is not in a location with feasible parking options. This is a good spot to casually sip and chat with a friend or two!

4272e7c5-24b4-4e40-a11f-f6b89b630236

This place has an extensive martini list! Amazing decor, lots of different seating options and very cool lighting! Service was great. We only tried a few tapas, but portions were small. All in all, a great date night spot or place to take visitors for apps & a martini or two before dinner.

de7e3d02-3939-454f-bebe-c4b20108d15d

Kali was great! Nice shared appetizers and great ambiance. We will be back on our next trip to Madison

530bd0b5-6c22-47c4-9cab-7c0d50461dad

Brenton made us the most fabulous martinis. So many choices and very reasonable. Don't walk by, stop and have a martini!

c2c76e25-3ce3-4c07-91c8-a56c8965670c

Service was great, we were a group of five with various check options needed and our server was so accommodating. She also gave great recommendations based on individual tastes. The atmosphere is casual but sophisticated, very nicely appointed. The drinks and food were exceptional. We ordered a variety of tapas and flatbreads to share. The Thai chicken flatbread was the only item that we thought could use improvement, maybe serve with a lime slice - it could use a touch of acid. Everything else was exceptional. Highly recommended!

Discover The Stuffed Olive in Madison, WI for exquisite dining and a cozy atmosphere. Savor delicious dishes that will leave you craving more. Book now

The Stuffed Olive Restaurant in Madison, WI - Unique Dining Experience

Madison

The Stuffed Olive

Wisconsin

Discover The Stuffed Olive in Madison, WI - a cozy restaurant with an extensive martini menu, delicious flatbreads, and a vibrant atmosphere for all occasions.

The Stuffed Olive Menu Overview

Signature Dishes

Beverages and Pairings

Dietary Options

Chef Recommendations

Experience the Menu at The Stuffed Olive

Paul's Club

Chazen Cafe

Whiskey River Saloon