Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee's Historic Third Ward, Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee was more than just your typical bakery. This airy and vibrant spot enchanted locals and visitors alike with its clever assortment of gourmet doughnuts and expertly brewed coffee. Known for a rotating menu that showcased vegan and gluten-free varieties, it quickly became a destination for doughnut lovers and morning risers looking for something special beyond the usual fare.
Holey Moley stood out with its artisanal approach to doughnuts. Whether you craved the rich decadence of a Toffee Mocha donut or the nutty delight of Pistachio, the flavors were crafted to surprise and satisfy. Seasonal specials like Pumpkin Spice kept the menu fresh and timely, ensuring a new reason to visit often. The shop’s commitment to quality ingredients and innovative combinations earned it rave reviews, and the vegan options were a particular highlight, drawing a dedicated following.
While seating was limited, most patrons embraced the takeout culture, grabbing their favorite treats to enjoy while exploring the vibrant neighborhood. The friendly staff added to the charm, making every visit feel welcoming and personal. Many customers recommended arriving early, as the doughnuts often sold out before mid-morning—proof of the shop’s immense popularity.
Though Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee permanently closed its Milwaukee location in June 2021, it left behind a sweet legacy. Customers frequently praised the shop for its creative doughnuts and excellent coffee offerings, highlighting the vegan selections and the warm, helpful atmosphere. Even years after closing, fans reminisce about the flavorful concoctions and the sense of community the shop fostered within the Historic Third Ward.
- Is Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee still open? No, Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee permanently closed its Milwaukee location in June 2021.
- What were some popular doughnut flavors at Holey Moley? Popular flavors included Toffee Mocha, Pistachio, Raspberry, and seasonal specials like Pumpkin Spice.
- Did Holey Moley offer vegan options? Yes, Holey Moley provided a variety of vegan doughnuts, with a rotating selection each day.
- Was there seating available at Holey Moley? The shop had limited seating, with most patrons opting for takeout.
- Could customers pre-order doughnuts from Holey Moley? Yes, customers had the option to pre-order doughnuts online for convenience.
Nestled in Milwaukee's Historic Third Ward, Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee carved out a distinct niche as the city's pioneering craft doughnut shop. Since its inception in 2014, it became synonymous with inventive gourmet doughnuts that delighted locals and visitors alike. Its airy, unique space invited guests to savor everything from classic cake doughnuts to rotating vegan and gluten-free varieties, elevating the doughnut experience beyond the ordinary.
Holey Moley’s story began in 2014 when it opened its doors on North Milwaukee Street in the vibrant Historic Third Ward. The shop quickly gained acclaim for its creative doughnut concoctions and welcoming atmosphere. Inspired by early success, the brand expanded in 2016 with a second location at the Mayfair Collection in Wauwatosa, aiming to bring its distinctive flavors to a broader audience.
However, the Wauwatosa store closed in 2018, marking a contraction after a promising expansion. The Milwaukee flagship location continued to attract doughnut devotees, renowned for its rotating menu that often included specialty doughnuts like the Diablo Rojo and vegan treats that catered to diverse dietary preferences.
In June 2021, after seven years of delighting Milwaukee’s doughnut lovers, Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee permanently closed its Milwaukee location. Despite this closure, the owners expressed a hopeful intention to reopen the concept in some form in the future, keeping alive the spirit of innovation and quality that defined the brand.
Vegan and gluten-free offerings that rotated regularly set Holey Moley apart from typical doughnut shops. Customers raved about creative flavors and the welcoming atmosphere. Despite being a little pricier than average, the unique taste and quality kept locals coming back.
- 2014 - Opening Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee launched in Milwaukee's Historic Third Ward, marking the city's first craft doughnut shop.
- 2016 - Expansion A second location opened in Wauwatosa's Mayfair Collection, extending the brand’s reach.
- 2018 - Contraction The Wauwatosa location closed after two years of operation.
- 2021 - Milwaukee location closes The flagship store in Milwaukee permanently closed, ending a significant chapter.
Located at 316 N Milwaukee St in Milwaukee's Historic Third Ward, Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee is a beloved bakery and café known for its unique and rotating selection of gourmet doughnuts, including vegan options. This airy space serves as a perfect spot for coffee lovers and doughnut enthusiasts alike.
- Unique and rotating selection of gourmet doughnuts.
- Vegan and gluten-free options available.
- Friendly and helpful staff.
- Early morning hours for fresh selection.
- Option to pre-order doughnuts online.
- Limited seating creates a cozy atmosphere.
- Limited seating.
- Early morning hours may not be convenient for all.
- Higher prices compared to chain doughnut shops.
- Limited availability of popular flavors later in the day.
- No decaf coffee available.
Holey Moley is perfect for early risers looking for a sweet start to their day, families wanting a fun treat, or anyone with a penchant for gourmet doughnuts. It's also a great spot for casual meet-ups or quick coffee breaks.
- Arrive early for the best selection.
- Check online for daily specials.
- Consider pre-ordering for larger groups.
Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee stands out as a delightful destination for anyone craving unique doughnuts in Milwaukee. With its friendly service and a commitment to quality, it’s a spot worth visiting, whether you're a local or just passing through.
Nestled at 316 North Milwaukee Street in the vibrant Historic Third Ward neighborhood of Milwaukee, Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee has become a beloved destination for locals and visitors craving an exceptional start to their day. This buzzing spot is far more than just a bakery — it's a celebration of inventive doughnut artistry paired with expertly brewed coffee in a bright, airy setting that invites you to linger.
Holey Moley has carved out a niche for itself with a standout assortment of doughnuts that keep customers coming back again and again. From classic cake doughnuts to imaginative daily rotating creations, their offerings are a playground of flavor and texture. Highlights include the Diablo Rojo — a decadent red velvet cake doughnut dipped in rich chocolate and topped with peanut butter chips and Nutella — and the Cookie Dough doughnut, featuring a glazed chocolate cake crowned with a generous heap of cookie dough.
Vegan and gluten-free options are thoughtfully crafted and rotate regularly, making Saturdays a special day dedicated to plant-based doughnut lovers. This focus on inclusivity ensures that everyone can indulge in a delicious and satisfying breakfast experience .
Complementing the doughnuts is a carefully curated coffee menu that energizes and warms you. Whether you prefer a robust cup to jumpstart your morning or a comforting hot chocolate to savor alongside your sweet treat, Holey Moley delivers with quality and care. While they don't serve decaf, their coffee offerings pair perfectly with dairy alternatives like soy and almond milk, catering to diverse tastes and dietary preferences.
- Arrive early – The freshest doughnuts sell out quickly, often before 9 a.m., so getting there early guarantees the best selection.
- Explore the rotating menu – Daily specials and seasonal creations mean there’s always something new to try, so visit often to discover your favorites.
- Bring cash or card with NFC – Convenient payment options, including contactless NFC, make your visit smooth and easy.
Holey Moley Doughnuts & Coffee stands as a shining example of Milwaukee’s dynamic food scene, melding creativity with quality in every bite and sip. Whether you're a foodie hunting for the best doughnut in town, a digital nomad seeking a cozy caffeine fix, or a trend-conscious traveler eager to sample local favorites, this spot delivers an unforgettable experience that celebrates indulgence with a friendly, neighborhood spirit.
