Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

London, England

Red Room

Copenhagen, Denmark

Delphine

Amsterdam, Netherlands

Chez Nina Green Brasserie

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Guide to

During Winter

Prague 

in Finland

The Northern Lights

Winter Edition

Paris

Best bars

New York Cities

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

On A Budget

5 Star Luxury Travel

You Must Visit

Eco-Friendly Hotels

Avoid Bali belly

How To:

That Are Worth The Trip

Dining Concepts

The World Is Slowing Down

Soft Travel

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Explore

Copenhagens Boutique Hotels

Discover

Tokyos best Ramen

Travel philosophy

The Rise of ‘Soft Travel’

Dublin Best Pubs

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Milwaukee, WI

North America

United States

# Eddie Martini's – Upscale Steakhouse in Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's is a renowned steakhouse located in Milwaukee, WI, known for its exceptional dining experience and cozy ambiance. Established in 1995, this restaurant has built a reputation for serving high-quality steaks, seafood, and a variety of delectable dishes. With a commitment to excellence, Eddie Martini's has become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors, offering a warm, inviting atmosphere that encourages guests to relax and enjoy their meals. Review highlights often mention the attentive service, delicious food, and the restaurant's intimate setting, making it a perfect choice for special occasions or casual dining.

## History
### The story of Eddie Martini's
Eddie Martini's was founded with a vision to create a premier dining destination that combines high-quality food with an intimate atmosphere. The founders aimed to provide a place where guests could enjoy exceptional steaks and seafood in a comfortable setting, reminiscent of classic American steakhouses. Over the years, Eddie Martini's has maintained this vision, continually striving to enhance the dining experience for its patrons.

### Milestones and growth
- Established in 1995, Eddie Martini's quickly gained popularity in the Milwaukee area.
- The restaurant has undergone several renovations to improve its ambiance and dining experience.
- It has received numerous accolades and positive reviews from food critics and patrons alike.
- Eddie Martini's has expanded its menu over the years, incorporating a variety of seafood and specialty dishes.
- The restaurant has become a staple for both locals and visitors, known for its commitment to quality and service.

### Cultural and local influence
Eddie Martini's has played a significant role in the local dining scene, contributing to Milwaukee's reputation as a culinary destination. The restaurant's focus on quality ingredients and traditional cooking techniques reflects the area's appreciation for fine dining. Additionally, Eddie Martini's has become a gathering place for celebrations, business meetings, and casual dinners, fostering a sense of community among its patrons.

### Continuing the tradition
As Eddie Martini's continues to thrive, the restaurant remains dedicated to its founding principles. The staff is trained to uphold the high standards of service and quality that have defined the establishment since its inception. By consistently updating the menu and enhancing the dining experience, Eddie Martini's ensures that it remains a beloved choice for both new and returning guests.

## Community
### Community involvement
Eddie Martini's actively engages with the local community, participating in various events and initiatives that support local causes. The restaurant often collaborates with local charities and organizations, hosting fundraisers and special events to give back to the community. This involvement has helped to strengthen the bond between Eddie Martini's and its patrons, fostering a sense of loyalty and appreciation.

### Community notion about the place
The community views Eddie Martini's as more than just a restaurant; it is seen as a cherished local institution. Many patrons have been dining at Eddie Martini's for years, often celebrating significant life events within its walls. The restaurant's reputation for excellent food and service has made it a go-to destination for special occasions, further solidifying its place in the hearts of the community.

### Events and gatherings
Eddie Martini's hosts a variety of events throughout the year, including wine tastings, holiday celebrations, and special themed dinners. These events not only showcase the restaurant's culinary offerings but also provide an opportunity for guests to connect with one another in a festive atmosphere. The restaurant's ability to cater to both large groups and intimate gatherings makes it a versatile venue for any occasion.

## Offerings
### What Eddie Martini's offers
Eddie Martini's prides itself on offering a diverse menu that features a range of high-quality steaks, fresh seafood, and delectable sides. The restaurant's commitment to using only the finest ingredients ensures that each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail. Guests can expect a memorable dining experience, whether they are indulging in a perfectly cooked steak or savoring a flavorful seafood dish.

### Dining and food experience
The dining experience at Eddie Martini's is characterized by a focus on quality and presentation. Each dish is thoughtfully prepared, with an emphasis on flavor and freshness. Guests often rave about the restaurant's signature items, such as the dry-aged steaks and seafood pasta, which showcase the culinary expertise of the kitchen staff. The attentive service further enhances the dining experience, ensuring that guests feel welcomed and well-cared for throughout their meal.

### Events and packages
Eddie Martini's offers various dining packages and special events that cater to different occasions. Whether it's a romantic dinner for two, a family celebration, or a corporate event, the restaurant provides tailored options to meet guests' needs. Special menus for holidays and events are also available, allowing patrons to enjoy a unique dining experience that reflects the season or occasion.

### Facilities and features
- Intimate dining rooms with a cozy atmosphere
- Outdoor patio for seasonal dining
- Full-service bar with an extensive wine and cocktail list
- Private dining options for special events
- Ample parking for guests

## Pros and Cons
### Key insights from reviews
Reviews of Eddie Martini's reveal a mix of experiences, highlighting both the strengths and areas for improvement. Many guests praise the quality of the food and the attentive service, while others note inconsistencies in their dining experiences. Overall, the restaurant maintains a positive reputation in the community.

### Compliments and strengths
- Exceptional quality of steaks and seafood
- Attentive and friendly service from staff
- Cozy and inviting atmosphere
- Consistently high standards of food preparation
- Positive experiences for special occasions and celebrations

### Contrasts and notable mentions
- Some guests have reported longer wait times for seating and service during busy periods.
- A few reviews mention inconsistencies in food quality, particularly with specific dishes.
- While many patrons enjoy the ambiance, others feel that it has changed over time, affecting their overall experience.

### Summary evaluation
Eddie Martini's remains a popular dining destination in Milwaukee, known for its high-quality food and welcoming atmosphere. While there are occasional discrepancies in service and food quality, the overall experience is often rated highly by patrons. The restaurant's commitment to excellence and community involvement continues to resonate with guests, making it a cherished establishment in the area.

## Location & Nearby Attractions
Eddie Martini's is conveniently located at 8612 W Watertown Plank Rd, Wauwatosa, WI, a suburb of Milwaukee. The restaurant is situated in a vibrant neighborhood that offers a variety of shopping and entertainment options. Guests can explore nearby attractions such as the Milwaukee County Zoo, the Wauwatosa Historical Society, and the scenic Hart Park, making it an ideal spot for a meal before or after a day of exploration. The area is easily accessible, with ample parking and public transportation options available.

## FAQs
**What type of cuisine does Eddie Martini's serve** Eddie Martini's specializes in steak and seafood dishes.
**Is there outdoor seating available** Yes, Eddie Martini's has a lovely outdoor patio for dining.
**Do I need a reservation** While reservations are recommended, walk-ins are welcome based on availability.
**What are the restaurant hours** Eddie Martini's typically operates for dinner service, with specific hours varying by day.
**Is there a dress code** The restaurant has a smart casual dress code, encouraging guests to dress nicely for their dining experience.

## Visit Eddie Martini's Today
Eddie Martini's invites you to experience its exceptional dining offerings in a warm and inviting atmosphere. With a rich history and a commitment to quality, this steakhouse has become a beloved part of the Milwaukee community. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, Eddie Martini's promises a memorable experience filled with delicious food and attentive service. Don't miss the chance to indulge in some of the finest steaks and seafood in the area!

ef26ca79-d8f6-4474-8f11-05e97d068b0a

One of the best experiences we've had. The crab cakes, bread, filet, mashed potatoes, hot fudge sundae and my French 75 was amazing! The service was unreal - they had three waitresses working our table so everything came out perfect and fast. The steak was made to perfection and the drinks tasted so good. I loved how medium dark it was in the restaurant. Couldn't have asked for a better meal.

6ce5145d-4b25-4866-b192-2637a5557a64

Food was good, service was okay- overall with price point it wasn't the best to my expectations but still a decent place for drinks and a nice steak. My boyfriend and I went on a Saturday evening for date night- he made reservations for 8pm the week before with no issues. We arrived to Eddie Martini's at around 7:50 and we were told that our table will take a few minutes to be prepared, which I understood since we were there early for our 8pm reservation. We weren't seated until 8:15, which was a very curious time for us to wait for a table we already had reserved ahead of time. The service was alright- the servers and hosts themselves were very kind and knowledgeable but in all it was a slow service, I'm guessing because of serving other tables. Still- we were seated at 8:15 only to then have left by 10:15, we were there for two hours which when you're sitting there is a long time to have a dinner. In terms of the food- overall delicious! I had the specialty item Australian Wagyu and my boyfriend had the veal and we both really liked the food, atleast!

fb591d7d-4caa-4899-a84b-810333200d5f

The steaks are excellent here! Also the drinks are fantastic! Very cozy inside. I have also sat outside on the patio in the summertime and it's wonderful!

6d988381-b56c-4ede-be3d-94d36de41e72

A solid option if you are in the area but not a destination. Appreciate they have been in business since 1995 and the interior exudes a comfortable steakhouse vibe. I opted for the dry aged NY strip for my dinner option along with a caesar salad. The steak was perhaps a smidge over my request for medium-rare and I don't if their aging did a whole lot. Service was on point. Overall, i thought the meal was good but not great.

82234f45-3196-4842-b15b-45c8bd846def

Wow! I discovered Eddie Martinis in passing and had to stop in. The second you walk in, you feel like you're taken back in time. It's small and intimate, but the food is the best part. I started with the flavorful lobster bisque and had decent chunks of lobster. For entrees, I got the seafood pasta, which was phenomenal. The pasta was perfectly cooked; if I'm not mistaken, I believe it was homemade. The sauce was creamy and delicious. And the amount of seafood was top tier. Every bite was better than the last. We got their three NY Strip special for the table: dry-aged, grass-fed, and wagyu strips. All amazing. For sides, I got to try the creamed corn, one of my favorite steakhouse sides. This was amazing too, as you can tell in the picture, most of it was gone before I got my helping. Overall, this was a fantastic dining experience, and the staff was terrific too. Our waitress, June, was excellent and so helpful.

0bc160c7-693e-4786-8e46-50879988d3ac

Nice restaurant great service however the food wasn't great my $79 dry aged NY strip steak just not worth the price I will say it was flavorful but not that tender, for me when I'm spending that much on a steak it should have been a memorable dinner

45aee52f-dcd6-41a7-a843-7bae2e1dfce2

I was celebrating so I stopped over without reservations to see if I could get in and I was given a choice of the bar or a small table up front so I chose the small table, I didn't stop at a fine dining restaurant to eat at the bar. They were busy and my server did a great job. I started with a whiskey old fashioned sour which was good. I ordered the baked burgundy onion soup and the veal scallopini because I love veal. The place is nice looking with a bar as you walk in. The baked burgundy onion soup was very good and looked amazing. There was a whole piece bread on top covered in a heap of melted cheese which washed boiling hot like most places so you could eat it right away. The veal scallopini was thin, lightly breaded on top of a lemon saffron risotto with a citrus cognac sauce topped with a leafy green and capers. The veal scallopini looked amazing and smelled delicious. The risotto was delicious with thin cross sliced asparagus which gave a nice crispy texture vs soft risotto. The veal was tender and delicious lightly breaded and not greasy after the pan fry. Overall this was a nice place for a good meal and a cocktail but I would recommend reservations because it was bar only for some walk ins and even the bar ended having a wait list.

eb989de6-d97c-4a18-bd17-38487a7a1229

Was here for work with private dinner. The service was good. Servers were attentive and worked hard for our large group. The food was okay... good and cooked well but I wasn't blown away by my filet. Average steakhouse.

2bc4083a-2f60-462e-bd96-4116ae79b406

It pains me to have to write this. I want to start with Eddie Martini's is my favorite restaurant & that's why we chose to celebrate my birthday there last night. I want to say that the Maitre d, Wayne is exceptional as well as our server Brooke. The reason for my 3 star review: I have been a 20+ year loyal patron and several things were a miss last night. Only the chef could be responsible. My absolute FAVORITE soup is the Baked Burgundy. I have travelled many places & NEVER found one better!! However, last night it had crunchy onions, the broth was off, half the size of a normal bowl and now it doesn't even include bread REALLY??? Honestly, that ruined my birthday and I'm so serious, because if this is their new chef we're not going back anytime soon. I only order lamb chops once/year out of respect for the lamb population. I wish I hadn't because there was barely any meat on them and what I did receive was hard to chew because it was fatty. I honestly wish they had let him live. I couldn't eat it. I'm going to add that my bf's duck was dry & overcooked and I had to drink water just to get it down. I felt terrible for him since he really wanted this night to be over the top for me. Needless to say, my cats will be eating the leftovers and if that is a new permanent chef we won't be back anytime soon. I hoped and expected better. The baked burgundy was so disappointing & half full with zero char that I couldn't even photograph it!

2d94f4f8-2369-4034-90f2-eaa6c63d766a

We came here for Valentines the weekend before. Unfortunately, it felt similar to other reviewers that if you're not a regular, you seem to be treated differently. Many servers just stopped to fill water or drop things off then bolted. We used to have a warmer welcome from our servers in the past. It used to feel like more of a supper club where everyone was a "regular". Also, while trying to finish the soup we watched as our server watched us finishing it so he could immediately remove the bowl from the table just as we finished. We felt rushed and unwanted. The food was okay - not worth the price these days. With their a la carte system, there seem to be better options elsewhere where these "sides" are included. I ordered my steak medium +. It came out closer to rare, but I was nervous to send it back and end up getting it overcooked or have my husband wait and his food would be cold. Personal preference: the veal reduction would've been better on the side. Otherwise, we liked the lighting and music, but that was about it. We would rather go elsewhere for a nice dinner.

Discover Eddie Martini's in Milwaukee, WI—an inviting restaurant offering delicious cuisine in Wauwatosa. Experience great food and warm ambiance today.

Eddie Martini's in Milwaukee, WI - Delicious Cuisine & Warm Ambiance

Wauwatosa

Eddie Martini's

Wisconsin

Explore the full menu at Eddie Martini's in Milwaukee, WI. Discover signature dishes, drinks & must-try items. Visit us at 8612 W Watertown Plank Rd.

Eddie Martini's Menu – Food & Drinks in Milwaukee, WI

Learn about Eddie Martini's in Milwaukee, WI. A top spot for delicious food, great drinks, and a lively atmosphere at 8612 W Watertown Plank Rd. Join us!

About Eddie Martini's, Milwaukee, WI

Opening hours for Eddie Martini's, Milwaukee, WI. Find opening hours for Eddie Martini's at 8612 W Watertown Plank Rd on our website.

Eddie Martini's Menu Overview

Signature Dishes

Beverages and Pairings

Dietary Options

Chef Recommendations

Experience the Menu at Eddie Martini's

The City Market Café & Bakehouse

Terrace Bistro

Seven Sisters Cafe