Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

London, England

Red Room

Copenhagen, Denmark

Delphine

Amsterdam, Netherlands

Chez Nina Green Brasserie

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Guide to

During Winter

Prague 

in Finland

The Northern Lights

Winter Edition

Paris

Best bars

New York Cities

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

On A Budget

5 Star Luxury Travel

You Must Visit

Eco-Friendly Hotels

Avoid Bali belly

How To:

That Are Worth The Trip

Dining Concepts

The World Is Slowing Down

Soft Travel

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Explore

Copenhagens Boutique Hotels

Discover

Tokyos best Ramen

Travel philosophy

The Rise of ‘Soft Travel’

Dublin Best Pubs

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Milwaukee, WI

North America

United States

# Outlaw Oyster – Seafood Restaurant in Milwaukee, WI
Outlaw Oyster is a vibrant seafood restaurant located in Milwaukee, WI, known for its fresh oysters and unique dining experience. Nestled within a cozy space, it offers a delightful menu featuring a variety of seafood dishes, including lobster rolls and specialty cocktails. The restaurant has quickly gained popularity for its Yappy Hour, where patrons can enjoy $2 oysters and other late-night bites. With a commitment to quality and a welcoming atmosphere, Outlaw Oyster has become a beloved spot for seafood lovers and casual diners alike.

## History
### The story of Outlaw Oyster
Outlaw Oyster was founded with a vision to bring the freshest seafood experience to Milwaukee, particularly focusing on oysters from various regions. The founders aimed to create a casual yet chic dining environment where seafood enthusiasts could gather to enjoy high-quality dishes and drinks. The concept was inspired by the founders' love for coastal cuisine and the vibrant culture surrounding seafood dining.

### Milestones and growth
- Launched in 2023, Outlaw Oyster quickly became a local favorite.
- Introduced the Yappy Hour, attracting a diverse crowd of seafood lovers.
- Expanded menu offerings based on customer feedback and seasonal availability.
- Collaborated with local suppliers to ensure fresh ingredients.

### Cultural and local influence
Outlaw Oyster has embraced the local culture by incorporating Milwaukee's unique culinary influences into its menu. The restaurant has become a gathering place for the community, showcasing local seafood and fostering a sense of camaraderie among diners. Its presence has also contributed to the revitalization of the North Avenue area, making it a popular destination for both locals and visitors.

### Continuing the tradition
As Outlaw Oyster continues to grow, it remains committed to its founding principles of quality and community. The restaurant regularly hosts events that celebrate seafood and local culture, ensuring that it stays connected to its roots while evolving to meet the needs of its patrons. The dedication to fresh ingredients and exceptional service is evident in every aspect of the dining experience.

## Community
### Community involvement
Outlaw Oyster actively participates in local events and initiatives, supporting various community causes. The restaurant collaborates with local fishermen and suppliers to promote sustainable seafood practices, reinforcing its commitment to the environment and the local economy. Additionally, Outlaw Oyster often hosts charity events, donating a portion of its proceeds to local organizations.

### Community notion about the place
The community views Outlaw Oyster as a refreshing addition to the Milwaukee dining scene. Many patrons appreciate the restaurant's focus on quality seafood and its inviting atmosphere. Reviews highlight the friendly service and the unique offerings that set Outlaw Oyster apart from other dining options in the area. The restaurant has quickly gained a reputation for being a go-to spot for seafood lovers.

### Events and gatherings
Outlaw Oyster hosts various events throughout the year, including seafood tastings, wine pairings, and special holiday menus. These events not only showcase the restaurant's culinary creativity but also foster a sense of community among diners. The intimate setting allows for personal interactions between staff and guests, enhancing the overall dining experience.

## Offerings
### What Outlaw Oyster offers
Outlaw Oyster specializes in a diverse range of seafood dishes, with a particular emphasis on oysters sourced from different regions. The menu features a variety of appetizers, entrees, and unique cocktails, all designed to complement the fresh seafood offerings. The restaurant's commitment to quality and flavor is evident in every dish, making it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.

### Dining and food experience
The dining experience at Outlaw Oyster is designed to be both casual and enjoyable. Guests can choose from a selection of fresh oysters, each with its own distinct flavor profile. The menu also includes popular items like lobster rolls, shrimp cocktails, and a variety of small plates perfect for sharing. The ambiance is cozy, with a mix of modern and rustic decor that enhances the overall dining experience.

### Events and packages
Outlaw Oyster offers special packages for events and gatherings, making it an ideal spot for celebrations and corporate functions. The restaurant can accommodate small to medium-sized groups, providing a personalized experience for guests. Additionally, the Yappy Hour features discounted oysters and drinks, creating a lively atmosphere for patrons to unwind after a long day.

### Facilities and features
- Cozy dining area with a mix of tables and bar seating
- Unique decor featuring local art and seafood-themed items
- Friendly and attentive staff
- Special events and themed nights
- Retail section for purchasing tinned seafood and sauces

## Pros and Cons
### Key insights from reviews
Reviews of Outlaw Oyster highlight a mix of positive experiences and constructive feedback. Many patrons rave about the freshness of the oysters and the friendly service, while others note areas for improvement in menu variety and consistency.

### Compliments and strengths
Customers frequently compliment the quality of the seafood, particularly the oysters, which are praised for their freshness and flavor. The atmosphere is described as cozy and inviting, making it a great spot for both casual dining and special occasions. The staff is often noted for their knowledge and attentiveness, enhancing the overall dining experience.

### Contrasts and notable mentions
Some reviews mention inconsistencies in menu offerings and the need for more variety. While many dishes receive high praise, a few items, such as the octopus hotdog sandwich, have garnered mixed reviews. Despite this, the overall sentiment remains positive, with many patrons expressing a desire to return.

### Summary evaluation
Overall, Outlaw Oyster has established itself as a prominent seafood destination in Milwaukee. With a focus on quality, community involvement, and a unique dining experience, it continues to attract seafood lovers and casual diners alike. The restaurant's commitment to fresh ingredients and exceptional service is evident in the overwhelmingly positive feedback from patrons.

## Location & Nearby Attractions
Outlaw Oyster is located at 6517 W North Ave, Wauwatosa, WI, a vibrant neighborhood in Milwaukee. The area is known for its eclectic mix of shops, cafes, and cultural attractions, making it a popular destination for both locals and visitors. Nearby attractions include parks, art galleries, and local boutiques, providing ample opportunities for exploration before or after dining at Outlaw Oyster. The restaurant's convenient location makes it easily accessible for those looking to enjoy a delicious seafood meal in a lively setting.

## FAQs
**What are the restaurant hours** Outlaw Oyster typically operates from late afternoon until late evening.
**Is there a happy hour** Yes, Outlaw Oyster features a Yappy Hour with discounted oysters and drinks.
**Do they offer takeout** Yes, Outlaw Oyster provides takeout options for those on the go.
**Are reservations required** Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours and special events.
**Is there parking available** Yes, there is street parking available near the restaurant.

## Visit Outlaw Oyster Today
Outlaw Oyster invites you to experience its exceptional seafood offerings in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. With a rich history rooted in community and quality, this restaurant has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Enjoy fresh oysters, delicious entrees, and a vibrant dining experience that captures the essence of coastal cuisine. Whether you're looking for a late-night bite or a casual dinner, Outlaw Oyster is the perfect destination for seafood lovers.

986987ff-cde0-490c-8d2f-1f9ffb04bd2f

Life gets busy, but nothing beats sneaking in a late-night date with my bestie. Fun fact: my first-ever oyster was with her in New Orleans, so of course, we had to keep the tradition alive at Outlaw Oyster. Before Yappy Hour even started, we were in seafood heaven--ordering oysters and some late-night bites. Here's what we tried: Aunt Dotty (Duxbury, MA) - petite but full of flavor, crisp brine with buttery sweetness. Bosu (Puget Sound, WA) - plump, picture-perfect, with cucumber and fresh grass notes. Pleasant Cove (Dam River, MA) - clean, briny, silky smooth... my absolute favorite. Madeleine Points (Yarmouth, ME) - bold brine, meaty bite, sweet finish. We couldn't stop there--bring on the rolls! The Connecticut Lobster Roll Sliders were perfectly seasoned and hands down the best lobster roll I've had. We even ordered two! The Green Goddess Shrimp Roll with poached shrimp, cucumber, red onion, arugula, and lemon on a toasted roll was also excellent. Drinks rounded out the night perfectly. I had the BA Strawberry Negroni, while my bestie went classic with the Outlaw Dirty Martini. Our server, Fin, was amazing--friendly, attentive, and made the drinks strong and delicious. The real star? Yappin', Thursday-Saturday from 8:30-10 PM. Late-night favorites like the Lobster Claw Basket and Shrimp Cocktail keep the seafood vibes going. Fresh seafood, great flavors, and unbeatable late-night energy make Outlaw Oyster the perfect spot for a late-night date--or just a fun seafood night. Highly recommend!

9f640b3a-befc-4b4a-9ba0-cf4d3ed8a7c8

I mostly went here to try their Yappy Hour, $2 oysters and it did not disappoint! It was a little confusing at first because the entrance to the restaurant is the same entrance as crafty cow but once you get inside you can let the host know that you're there for outlaw oyster and they will lead you to a table. The interior was very cozy and cute. They have a "larger" seating area next to a smaller nook-like room by the bar. The bar area, had shelves of tin fish, wine, cookbooks, and sauces that you could buy. I only got their oyster shooter and the oysters. I'm not gonna lie, I wasn't a fan of the oyster shooter but mostly because I'm not the biggest fan of bloody Mary's. The combo was very interesting to say the least. The oyster that came with the shooter was pretty big but a little grainy. The yappy hour oysters were perfect and fresh. They came with three different sauces and lemons (I think a pickled onion, a green sauce, and a red one.) Just as fast as it came out, they were gone! The food, ambiance, and service was great. Definitely will come again!

c7983560-d2a1-4868-b312-8425ceb4adfa

First of all, I love oysters and seafood. I will admit I was skeptical of an oyster place opening in a strip center on North Ave in Tosa, but the oysters themselves were really good! We found this spot on a random weekend, and were the only ones in the space for happy hour. It felt lonely and not quite ready with us being the only ones, not even a bartended around, but it was also quiet when we were there. I loved the little collection of items to shop, including tinned fish, which are growing in popularity. Having a spritz of the day is also fantastic in the summer heat and always goes well with oysters! I felt like their menu was lacking a little bit in variety, but they were also still getting their feet under them. I'll have to give them another try now that they are here to stay!

d9440b28-26c9-436d-9a3e-d3b55e59e07b

Such a cute and cozy place with a hip feel to it. A mix of bougie east coast noshes meets a Texan dessert dweller. Stated off with a tasty strawberry negroni to wet the pallet. I learned that they infuse their campari with strawberries which ends up making the, usually bitter campari, a bit smoother and slightly sweeter. The pimento dip was delicious! Tip: ask for more crackers if you run out and some kelp hot pepper crisp to give the dip a bit of a kick. I tried one of their tin fishes and opted with a vegan and gnocchi mushroom crab option. It came with a full platter of mini pickles, cheese slices, mini crispy toasts, and, a lemon crema, and crispy chili oil. They have a lot of different tinned seafood to buy, and I liked that they were utilizing those same ones you can buy off their shelves as an option to have in the restaurant so you can taste essentially before you buy. Bartender was friendly and attentive. Don't forget to grab a (Free!) candy cigarette before you leave!

cab989d0-b456-4c6f-a229-27c77919dce8

Checked out this spot and grabbed a burger to go. The OK Burger comes with waffle fries and it is full of flavor. The restaurant is adjacent to the Crafty Cow, same owner. It gives a more personal feel for the dining experience. Plenty of tables and great use of space. There is also a bar on that side. The service was great. Finn was knowledgeable and very friendly.

06e7d20f-3daf-4e14-bbf5-ef554b93eea4

Great new spot, get here early! The oyster's offered are unique, fresh, and the staff will recommend the best oysters (who are we kidding they're all good!). An oyster happy hour is all you need. Loved the smoked salmon plate, mini martinis, and spritz options. The lobster roll sliders were good but not $35 good. I was a bit disappointed in the amount of lobster presented. The hand cut chips were decent. Overall Outlaw Oyster is a vibe for happy hour oyster deals and you have to try the smoked salmon plate. I will definitely be back when the weather is warmer.

76122a82-3602-4b36-8cff-0e7352d4178c

What a cute, eclectic new spot on north avenue. We ordered half a dozen oysters and enjoyed all of them, they were so fresh! My husband got the burger with lobster and it was SO good and unique, I got the lobster rolls and I highly recommend them. Definitely try to visit during their yappy hour, as they have really great deals twice a day. Not only was the food great, the service from Raih was AMAZING! she was so friendly and made the whole experience better, she even read my husband like a book and made him a manhattan LOL!

16ccff11-7945-40b8-91b9-e83bcf12128f

This location is inside Crafty Cow. The smell when you walked in to the spot for Outlaw smelled kind of like stale beer. The table we sat at was very sticky (I know that can happen with certain types of finishing on tables so not docking them for that). We were greeted with a complimentary tasting of their house wine which was really tasty. We ordered the daily spritz and the outlaw beer, both were good. For food, we ordered all four of the daily oysters, the octopus aguachile, and the octopus hotdog sandwich. Oysters and aguachile were both fantastic; however, the chips with the aguachile were so over salted we found ourselves brushing off salt before dipping. The octopus hotdog was pretty disappointing. The octopus was pretty over cooked and had the consistency of jerky. We only had a few bites and then ate the toppings and roll. It was pretty disappointing for the price of the sandwich ($24) and the place specializing in seafood. The sandwich was also topped with roe. The roe was fishier than it should have been and pretty off putting. All in all, we haven't had a lot of good experiences at Crafty Cow and if we had known they were the same group, we probably wouldn't have gone in the first place.

1b939cb2-1eaf-47d8-962a-49246e104ad6

A great date place. A small quiet place with 3 tables and a small bar area and small menu. But the food is very good. We ordered the Smoked Whitefish Dip that is served with crackers, shrimp cocktail and the Smoked Fish Trio Platter. Also had the mini'tini, which is a small version of their Outlaw Dirty Martini. The food is wonderful and has great flavor. Finn, our server was absolutely the best server/bartender. Outlaw Oyster will be on the list for date night dining.

831dfde3-5c44-4a91-9217-2e4bb597bc7c

The food was brought out quickly and was incredible! We sat in the nook by the bar and I loved this table so much! By all the cute decorations!

Discover Outlaw Oyster in Milwaukee, WI—your premier destination for fresh oysters and seafood. Experience a vibrant dining atmosphere today.

Outlaw Oyster in Milwaukee - Fresh Seafood & Vibrant Dining

Wauwatosa

Outlaw Oyster

Wisconsin

Explore the full menu at Outlaw Oyster in Milwaukee, WI. Discover signature dishes, drinks & must-try items. Visit us at 6517 W North Ave, Wauwatosa.

Outlaw Oyster Menu – Food & Drinks in Milwaukee, WI

Learn about Outlaw Oyster, a premier seafood restaurant located at 6517 W North Ave, Wauwatosa, Milwaukee. Discover our story, chef, and what makes us special.

About Outlaw Oyster in Milwaukee, WI

Opening hours for Outlaw Oyster, Milwaukee, WI. Find opening hours for Outlaw Oyster, Milwaukee on 6517 W North Ave.

Outlaw Oyster Menu Overview

Signature Dishes

Beverages and Pairings

Dietary Options

Chef Recommendations

Experience the Menu at Outlaw Oyster

Birch

Tosa Block Party

Drunken Cobra