Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

London, England

Red Room

Copenhagen, Denmark

Delphine

Amsterdam, Netherlands

Chez Nina Green Brasserie

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Guide to

During Winter

Prague 

in Finland

The Northern Lights

Winter Edition

Paris

Best bars

New York Cities

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

On A Budget

5 Star Luxury Travel

You Must Visit

Eco-Friendly Hotels

Avoid Bali belly

How To:

That Are Worth The Trip

Dining Concepts

The World Is Slowing Down

Soft Travel

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Explore

Copenhagens Boutique Hotels

Discover

Tokyos best Ramen

Travel philosophy

The Rise of ‘Soft Travel’

Dublin Best Pubs

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Milwaukee, WI

North America

United States

# Nicos Pizza – Authentic Pizza Experience in Milwaukee, WI
Nicos Pizza, located in Milwaukee, WI, is a beloved restaurant known for its delicious pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. This establishment has gained a reputation for its high-quality ingredients and unique toppings, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a history rooted in community and culinary excellence, Nicos Pizza offers a dining experience that reflects its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The restaurant has received numerous positive reviews highlighting its flavorful pizzas, friendly service, and vibrant ambiance, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers.

## History
### The story of Nicos Pizza
Nicos Pizza was founded with a vision to create a neighborhood pizzeria that emphasizes quality ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere. The founders aimed to provide a dining experience where guests could enjoy delicious food while feeling at home. Over the years, Nicos Pizza has become a staple in the Milwaukee community, known for its commitment to culinary excellence and customer service.

### Milestones and growth
- Established in the early 2000s, Nicos Pizza quickly gained popularity for its unique pizza offerings.
- The restaurant expanded its menu to include a variety of toppings and styles, catering to diverse tastes.
- Nicos Pizza opened a new location in West Allis, further solidifying its presence in the Milwaukee area.
- The restaurant has participated in local food festivals, showcasing its signature dishes and engaging with the community.

### Cultural and local influence
Nicos Pizza has played a significant role in the local culinary scene, contributing to Milwaukee's reputation as a food destination. The restaurant's focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients resonates with the community's values, fostering a sense of pride among residents. By supporting local suppliers and participating in community events, Nicos Pizza has established itself as a beloved institution in the area.

### Continuing the tradition
As Nicos Pizza continues to grow, it remains dedicated to its founding principles. The restaurant consistently seeks to innovate its menu while maintaining the quality and flavors that have made it a favorite among patrons. By listening to customer feedback and adapting to changing tastes, Nicos Pizza ensures that it remains a relevant and cherished part of the Milwaukee dining landscape.

## Community
### Community involvement
Nicos Pizza actively engages with the local community through various initiatives. The restaurant often collaborates with local organizations and participates in charity events, demonstrating its commitment to giving back. By hosting fundraisers and donating a portion of its proceeds to local causes, Nicos Pizza fosters a strong connection with its patrons and the surrounding neighborhood.

### Community notion about the place
Locals view Nicos Pizza as more than just a restaurant; it is a gathering place where friends and families come together to enjoy good food and company. The warm and inviting atmosphere, coupled with the friendly staff, creates a sense of belonging among regulars. Many patrons appreciate the restaurant's dedication to quality and its role in the community, often recommending it to newcomers and visitors.

### Events and gatherings
Nicos Pizza hosts various events throughout the year, including pizza-making classes, trivia nights, and live music performances. These gatherings not only provide entertainment but also foster a sense of community among attendees. The restaurant's spacious layout allows for private events and celebrations, making it a popular choice for parties and gatherings.

## Offerings
### What Nicos Pizza offers
Nicos Pizza offers a diverse menu that caters to a wide range of tastes. While the restaurant is primarily known for its pizzas, it also features a selection of appetizers, salads, and desserts. The commitment to using high-quality ingredients is evident in every dish, ensuring a satisfying dining experience for all guests.

### Dining and food experience
The dining experience at Nicos Pizza is characterized by its casual yet vibrant atmosphere. Guests can choose to dine in or take out, with many opting for the latter due to the restaurant's convenient location. The menu features a variety of pizza styles, including traditional thin crust and specialty pies, allowing customers to customize their orders with an array of toppings. Reviewers frequently highlight the freshness of the ingredients and the unique flavor combinations, making each visit a delightful culinary adventure.

### Events and packages
Nicos Pizza offers various event packages for groups looking to celebrate special occasions. Whether it's a birthday party, corporate event, or family gathering, the restaurant provides customizable options to suit different needs. These packages often include a selection of pizzas, appetizers, and beverages, ensuring a memorable experience for all attendees.

### Facilities and features
- Spacious dining area for large groups
- Full-service bar with a variety of beverages
- Outdoor seating for pleasant weather
- Takeout and delivery options for convenience
- Regular events and live entertainment

## Pros and Cons
### Key insights from reviews
Reviews of Nicos Pizza reveal a mix of experiences, with many patrons praising the quality of the food and the friendly service. However, some customers have noted inconsistencies in their dining experiences, particularly regarding wait times and food preparation.

### Compliments and strengths
Many reviews commend Nicos Pizza for its flavorful pizzas, generous toppings, and quality ingredients. The restaurant's commitment to customer satisfaction is often highlighted, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a positive experience. The inviting atmosphere and community involvement also receive high marks from patrons.

### Contrasts and notable mentions
While most reviews are positive, some customers have expressed dissatisfaction with specific aspects, such as the dryness of the pizza or issues with service during busy times. These contrasting experiences suggest that while Nicos Pizza excels in many areas, there is room for improvement in consistency and service efficiency.

### Summary evaluation
Overall, Nicos Pizza is well-regarded for its delicious food and community-oriented approach. While some reviews indicate areas for improvement, the restaurant's strengths in quality and customer service make it a popular choice for pizza lovers in Milwaukee.

## Location & Nearby Attractions
Nicos Pizza is conveniently located at 9638 W National Ave, West Allis, WI, a suburb of Milwaukee. This area is known for its vibrant community and accessibility to various attractions. Visitors can explore nearby parks, shopping centers, and cultural sites, making it an ideal spot for a meal before or after a day of activities. The restaurant's location also allows easy access to public transportation, enhancing its appeal to both locals and tourists.

## FAQs
**What are the hours of operation** Nicos Pizza typically operates from 11 AM to 10 PM on weekdays and later on weekends.  
**Does Nicos Pizza offer delivery** Yes, Nicos Pizza provides delivery options for customers.  
**Is there outdoor seating available** Yes, Nicos Pizza features outdoor seating for guests to enjoy.  
**Can I host a private event at Nicos Pizza** Yes, the restaurant offers event packages for private gatherings.  
**What types of pizza does Nicos Pizza serve** Nicos Pizza serves a variety of pizza styles, including thin crust and specialty pies.

## Visit Nicos Pizza Today
Nicos Pizza invites you to experience its delicious offerings and welcoming atmosphere in Milwaukee, WI. With a rich history and strong community ties, this restaurant is dedicated to providing an exceptional dining experience. Whether you're craving a classic pizza or exploring unique flavor combinations, Nicos Pizza is the perfect destination for food lovers. Come and enjoy the vibrant ambiance, friendly service, and mouthwatering dishes that have made Nicos Pizza a favorite among locals.

4bd4c4e6-b007-4445-9c05-85fbf868da77

while overall the pizza tasted good, it lacked sauce. it was pretty dry. for $24 i expected more than dry pizza. crust was not too hard and the cheese was nice. just very very dry pizza.

1a276fc0-0fea-4c9f-a5d0-4510d9066115

I did take out but the place looked really nice with some regulars sitting at the bar. The toppings on this pizza are impressive. You can tell they focus on using the best quality ingredients. Toppings go to the edge of the pizza and sausage is plentiful. Mushrooms and onions are so fresh! The crust was really thin but not cracker like but I did take this to go. Sauce had good flavor and wasn't too sweet. Toppings 10 Crust 8 Sauce 9 Value 8 It seems pricey but it's not because this pizza is so filling. Definitely worth a stop.

ef83d99b-1ec0-43a0-a211-949e40697c42

My daughter and I stopped in here for dinner. Unfortunately there is a lot of road construction around the restaurant, but you can get in from the front and partial side street. There were plenty of tables available and our waitress was good. She recommended some drinks and pizzas. We went with half cheese for my daughter and the Catania. The Catania was unique and very good. I would definitely come back and try some of the other pizzas.

c501e276-7cc0-4c37-a552-bbf5d8c63372

We stopped in for lunch on a Saturday and really enjoyed the food at this neighborhood pizza joint. It was sort of quiet on a Saturday at lunch- I think it is more of an evening spot perhaps as it looked like they even had a set up for a live dj. There's all sorts of interesting combinations on the pizza menu but if you are a meat eater, you absolutely must get one with their luscious house made Italian sausage-among the most flavorful that I've ever had and would be reason enough to get me back in there next time I find myself in Milwaukee. Service was friendly but it took a while for the food to arrive, we ordered a large and a medium and that was more than the 5 of us (adults) could eat. Definitely recommended

f3b54183-dec6-4dfd-9e73-975b4004c45a

I had this place on my list of places to try as it has been consistently featured on my Milwaukee Foodie group in Facebook. I am SO GLAD I asked friends to meet here--it was awesome food! We sat at a big bar and the bartender was friendly. We got garlic bread with cheese and then two pizzas---I have nothing bad or constructive to say about either--both were so darn good! Great amount of cheese and toppings. The next time I'm in West Allis, I'm absolutely getting pizza here..

79383d96-5690-49f8-ae74-fc0edefea019

Ordered the Sharp Dressed Man pizza to go. Their homemade sausage is the best sausage I've ever had on a pizza. I loved the sauce as well - it's very well-seasoned. Definitely a unique and delicious pub pizza to try!

ffad1ada-8aa8-45e6-926d-c4fa1a2bab29

I have had many good times in this bar. However, this week on Wednesday September 24th, 2025, a woman who was not an employee grabbed me from behind. This woman did not let go of me when I asked her to, and she continued holding on to me for several seconds. This woman finally released me from her grip when the bartender asked her to several seconds later. This is not necessarily a negative review of the bar itself. However, it is worth stating that I personally had a very negative experience at this bar on a Wednesday evening. My advice? Stay away from this bar on Wednesday evenings.

50ad6392-6f4b-4c42-beb3-36366aacdbc3

The worst pizza I had. It was burnt and the pieces on top were way too big. Had an appetizer of mozzarella medallions and they were awful. They are served with balsamic vinegar which does not compliment the dish at at. Also, too much breading on the mozzarella. It was very loud in there and there is no accessible restroom for someone in a wheelchair. Will never go back.

f19594f7-8580-46d4-9ced-2808e2579693

Visited Nico's for the first time today. A friend raved about their Oconomowoc location, so I was looking forward to trying them. I bought one of their frozen pizzas at Metcalfe's Market for $16 and was disappointed. Today's experience at their new West Allis location, in the former Crawdaddy's and Shakey's space, was a great experience! I ordered the 12" Classic, which is topped with BIG chunks of Italian Sausage, red onions, and fresh mushrooms, and I added pepperoni. The first thing I noticed was how thick the pizza was with cheese and toppings. Then I picked up a slice and was surprised by how well the crispy, Tavern Cut, slice held the heavy toppings. This was true of the center slices, as well. Super thin crust that doesn't flop or get soft in the center! That speaks to the quality of the ingredients, how well the pizza dough is made, and the temperature of the oven. The pizza tasted great, and I will be back. It may already be in my top 5 favorite thin crust pizzas in Milwaukee.

50784a38-71e0-46a9-984b-daa44c552ee4

This was our first time at Nico's and we'll definitely be back. Killer pie. The pizza was outstanding. Thin, crispy crust. A well balanced sauce (not too sweet and not too savory--just right). Vinny's sausage is always a win for us, it's the best and the rest of our toppings: pepperoni, onion, black olives- all held their own as well. I have to admit we had a small issue with our order and a staff shift change that was taking place. Totally get it, sometimes these things happen...But you know what? They went out of their way to acknowledge it and make up for it. Honestly, it was so refreshing. Class act. And we will be back to try other things on the menu. There are some buffalo chicken thighs that are just waiting for me.

Discover Nicos Pizza in Milwaukee, WI—your go-to spot for delicious, authentic pizza. Visit us at 9638 W National Ave for a flavorful dining experience.

Nicos Pizza in Milwaukee, WI - Authentic Pizza at West Allis

West Allis

Nicos Pizza

Wisconsin

Explore the full menu at Nicos Pizza in Milwaukee, WI. Discover signature dishes, drinks & must-try items. Visit us at 9638 W National Ave, West Allis.

Nicos Pizza Menu – Food & Drinks in Milwaukee, WI

Learn about Nicos Pizza, a beloved restaurant in Milwaukee, WI. Offering delicious pizza, friendly service, and a cozy atmosphere at 9638 W National Ave.

About Nicos Pizza in Milwaukee, WI

Opening hours for Nicos Pizza, Milwaukee, WI. Find opening hours for Nicos Pizza, Milwaukee, WI on 9638 W National Ave.

Nicos Pizza Menu Overview

Signature Dishes

Beverages and Pairings

Dietary Options

Chef Recommendations

Experience the Menu at Nicos Pizza

The Network

Just J's

Scooter's Tap