Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

London, England

Red Room

Copenhagen, Denmark

Delphine

Amsterdam, Netherlands

Chez Nina Green Brasserie

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Guide to

During Winter

Prague 

in Finland

The Northern Lights

Winter Edition

Paris

Best bars

New York Cities

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

On A Budget

5 Star Luxury Travel

You Must Visit

Eco-Friendly Hotels

Avoid Bali belly

How To:

That Are Worth The Trip

Dining Concepts

The World Is Slowing Down

Soft Travel

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Explore

Copenhagens Boutique Hotels

Discover

Tokyos best Ramen

Travel philosophy

The Rise of ‘Soft Travel’

Dublin Best Pubs

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Milwaukee, WI

North America

United States

# Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli – Unique Sandwich Spot in Milwaukee, WI
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli, located in Milwaukee, WI, is a charming restaurant specializing in gourmet sandwiches that revolve around the classic peanut butter and jelly theme. Established in 2017, this deli offers a nostalgic dining experience with a fun twist, featuring a menu that includes unique peanut butter and jam combinations, as well as a variety of breads and toppings. The deli has garnered a loyal following due to its fresh ingredients, friendly service, and creative offerings, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors. With a cozy ambiance adorned with vintage lunch boxes, it’s a delightful spot to enjoy a meal that brings back childhood memories.

## History
### The story of Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli was founded with a vision to reinvent the classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich, transforming it into a gourmet experience. The founders aimed to create a space where nostalgia meets creativity, allowing customers to explore a variety of flavors and combinations that elevate the traditional PB&J. This unique concept quickly gained traction, appealing to both children and adults who share a love for this timeless sandwich.

### Milestones and growth
- **2017**: Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli opens its doors to the public.
- **2018**: Gained recognition at local farmers' markets, expanding its customer base.
- **2020**: Introduced new menu items and expanded offerings, including unique jams and peanut butter varieties.
- **2021**: Received positive reviews and increased foot traffic, solidifying its place in the community.
- **2022**: Began hosting small events and gatherings, enhancing community engagement.

### Cultural and local influence
The deli has become a cultural staple in Milwaukee, blending local flavors with a beloved childhood classic. Its presence at farmers' markets has not only introduced its products to a wider audience but has also fostered a sense of community among local food enthusiasts. The deli's commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients resonates with the growing trend of supporting local businesses, further embedding it into the fabric of Milwaukee's culinary scene.

### Continuing the tradition
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli continues to honor the classic sandwich while innovating its offerings. By regularly updating its menu and incorporating seasonal ingredients, the deli ensures that it remains relevant and appealing to both new and returning customers. The founders' dedication to quality and creativity reflects a commitment to keeping the tradition of the peanut butter and jelly sandwich alive, while also pushing its boundaries.

## Community
### Community involvement
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli actively engages with the local community through various initiatives. The deli participates in local farmers' markets, where it showcases its unique peanut butter and jelly products. Additionally, it hosts events that bring people together, fostering a sense of belonging and community spirit. This involvement has helped the deli build strong relationships with its customers and local vendors.

### Community notion about the place
The community views Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli as a delightful and innovative addition to Milwaukee's dining landscape. Customers appreciate the friendly atmosphere and the nostalgic decor, which evokes fond memories of childhood lunches. The deli is often described as a cozy and inviting space, making it a popular spot for families and friends to gather and enjoy a meal together.

### Events and gatherings
The deli hosts various events, including small comedy shows and themed gatherings, which enhance its community presence. These events not only provide entertainment but also create opportunities for locals to connect and socialize. The deli's commitment to hosting community-centric events reflects its dedication to being more than just a restaurant; it aims to be a gathering place for all.

## Offerings
### What Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli offers
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli offers a diverse menu centered around the beloved peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Customers can choose from a variety of gourmet sandwiches, each crafted with high-quality ingredients. The deli also sells unique peanut butter and jam products, allowing customers to recreate their favorite sandwiches at home. The emphasis on customization ensures that every visit can yield a new and exciting culinary experience.

### Dining and food experience
The dining experience at Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli is characterized by its cozy ambiance and friendly service. Guests can enjoy a range of sandwiches, from classic combinations to creative new twists. The option to build your own sandwich allows for personalization, catering to individual tastes and preferences. The deli's commitment to freshness is evident in every bite, with house-made jams and peanut butter that enhance the overall flavor profile.

### Events and packages
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli offers various packages for special occasions, making it an ideal choice for parties and gatherings. Customers can order catering options that include a selection of sandwiches, sides, and drinks, ensuring that everyone can enjoy the deli's unique offerings. The flexibility in menu options allows for customization based on dietary preferences and event themes.

### Facilities and features
- Cozy dining area with nostalgic decor
- Outdoor seating options
- Takeout and delivery services
- Variety of gourmet peanut butter and jelly products for sale
- Friendly and knowledgeable staff ready to assist

## Pros and Cons
### Key insights from reviews
Reviews of Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli highlight the deli's unique concept and friendly service. Many customers express their delight at the variety of options available, praising the quality of the ingredients used. However, some reviews mention concerns about pricing and specific menu items that may not meet expectations.

### Compliments and strengths
Customers frequently compliment the deli's innovative menu and the ability to customize sandwiches. The friendly and patient staff receive high praise for their willingness to assist and provide recommendations. The nostalgic decor and cozy atmosphere also contribute to a positive dining experience, making it a favorite among families and friends.

### Contrasts and notable mentions
While many reviews are overwhelmingly positive, a few customers have noted that certain sandwiches may not be worth the price, particularly if the bread does not meet their expectations. Additionally, some have expressed a desire for more traditional peanut butter options, as the deli primarily focuses on natural varieties. Despite these contrasts, the overall sentiment remains highly favorable.

### Summary evaluation
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli stands out as a unique dining destination in Milwaukee, offering a creative twist on a classic favorite. While there are minor critiques regarding specific menu items, the overall experience is characterized by quality ingredients, friendly service, and a nostalgic atmosphere. This deli has successfully carved out a niche in the local culinary scene, appealing to both young and old.

## Location & Nearby Attractions
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli is located at 6125 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, WI, a suburb of Milwaukee. This area is known for its vibrant community and proximity to various attractions, including local parks and shopping centers. Visitors to the deli can easily explore the surrounding neighborhood, which offers a mix of dining, shopping, and recreational opportunities. The deli's location makes it a convenient stop for those exploring the greater Milwaukee area, providing a unique dining experience amidst a lively community.

## FAQs
**What are the hours of operation** The deli is open for lunch and dinner, with varying hours throughout the week.
**Is there parking available** Yes, there is ample parking available near the deli.
**Do they offer vegetarian options** Yes, the deli provides vegetarian-friendly sandwich choices.
**Can I order online** Yes, customers can place orders online for pickup or delivery.
**Are there gluten-free options** The deli offers gluten-free bread for those with dietary restrictions.

## Visit Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli Today
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli invites you to explore its unique offerings, where nostalgia meets creativity in every sandwich. With a welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and a menu that celebrates the beloved peanut butter and jelly combination, this deli is a must-visit destination in Milwaukee. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a fun dining experience with family and friends, Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli promises to deliver satisfaction with every bite.

4c865a26-d617-4310-b0a6-f28ec87ea50d

We were going to stop at another sandwich spot after we went to the West Allis farmers but saw it on the way and it sounded delicious. Just looking at the menu our mouth was watering. You walk in and it's the cutest sandwich shop as they have old metal lunch boxes hanging throughout and such a fun menu board on the wall. Not only do they sell sandwiches they sell peanut butter and different jams with fun flavors like guava, dandelion and more! I got the Strawberry Lovers on panini and it was amazing. I can't wait to go back again. They make all their jams and peanut butter and it was so fresh. Also I have to talk about how amazing the guest service was. We came in about 20 minutes prior to close and decided to get it to go because we didn't want to be those people. However, when they gave us our sandwiches they said it was fine to eat in and really no trouble at all. We still ended up taking it to go but I feel like most establishments wouldn't offer that. Overall this is amazing place and I can't wait to come back.

f247b8bf-c36f-41ca-812c-a476d7e14838

Such a unique idea and so many different options. They also have a lot of peanut butter options and jam options for sale and I can confirm that they are also delicious. Cozy and informal to eat inside. A great inspiration for changing up your pb&j game.

a696c4b9-9d29-4827-bd20-eea9c8642678

What's there's not to love about a PB&J paradise? We actually first discovered their peanut butter at the oak creek farmers market and when we ran out we went back the following Saturday to discover they're every other weekend at the market... BUT they are an actual Deli! Build your own PB&Js different peanut butters different jelly's and jams an array of breads and toppings to choose from, grilled or not grilled... the possibilities are endless and we restocked on their honey roasted peanut butter. If you don't want to build your own their menu has lots of options for you to choose from as well. I did a grilled panini bread with cinnamon peanut butter the hot raspberry jam and banana slices... delicious. The kids loved it too! No complaints from our family. The folks here were really patient and kind answered all my random questions . Love old school lunch boxes all around as decor as well! Cool place

65a0a3f3-e898-4508-9cfb-86acfd2027e6

What a cool concept! I've been waiting to get here for quite a long time. I love how you can customize your daughter cravings from bread to accompany mince. The place has a beautiful vibe of nostalgia and creativity. When you want a new twist this is it!

ee265933-87dd-46b5-8054-eba6dc9d1436

If you're a fan of peanut butter, jelly, or the classic combo of the two, this place is a must-visit! We first discovered their Honey Roasted Peanut Butter at a farmers market and instantly fell in love. It's the perfect blend of creamy and chunky and great with anything. We had said when we bought it that we would have to make it a point to go to the store and try some of the menu. When we ran out of peanut butter it was the perfect excuse. The inside is decorated with old lunchboxes (that you can buy or trade) and has that nostalgia feel that pairs perfectly with a PB&J. The staff is incredibly friendly and patient, happily guiding you through the menu full of delicious pre-made combinations and plenty of options to customize your order. I opted for the Bagel PB, featuring Honey Roasted Peanut Butter, honey, and cinnamon on a grilled bagel--absolutely divine! My husband tried The King, a grilled sandwich loaded with Honey Roasted Peanut Butter, sliced bananas, honey, and bacon. We also shared a cup of Tomato Basil Soup from The Soup Market and enjoyed their signature Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli Root Beer. Everything was flavorful, satisfying, and filling. Before leaving, we couldn't resist grabbing another tub of their Honey Roasted Peanut Butter to take home.

d540538a-e406-4da4-b96c-b5c26c526525

I stopped at Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli a couple times after they opened in 2017, but had since forgot about them as I discovered lunch spots closer to work. I recently wanted a PB&J at home (we were out of jelly though **sad**) so having one for lunch sounded good. I ordered the Grilled Cheese & Jelly on Vienna white bread with American cheese and grape jelly. I also ordered the Double Decker on 7 grain wheat bread with natural peanut butter and strawberry kiwi jam. As a kid my mom would make me a cheese and jelly sandwich for cold lunch at school, so the Grilled Cheese & Jelly was super nostalgic. The sandwich was large (appreciated for the price) and the grape jelly was great. The American cheese was a little overpowered by the jelly, but not enough to be a problem. I'd get this again. I didn't love the 7 grain wheat bread on the Double Decker. It was a little dense, so the sandwich sat heavy as I ate it and the bread flavor was almost too strong. They don't have smooth style peanut butter that I prefer, so I went with the natural peanut butter which has lots of small pieces of peanuts in it. It's not my favorite kind, but it was good for what it was. I thought it was odd that their strawberry kiwi is just strawberry jelly and kiwi jam separate from each other, not mixed together as one jam. I probably wouldn't get the Double Decker again, but can't fault anyone that does. I bought a couple of Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli branded sodas too, specifically the root beer and strawberry rhubarb. I've only opened the root beer so far and, while it's not Sprecher, it's pretty good.

a6b8e367-3a53-43b8-abb7-18a08638ca54

What a delicious idea! The fresh peanut butter with the strawberry, and the sliced strawberries. The Mrs and I loved it

860958d5-e7b6-4022-bbb1-f5cc85b2bac8

I had the King. It was fantastic. I never knew this place existed. The food was great and I also bought chocolate peanut butter, jelly salsa and the jelly liqueur. They were all awesome! Really cool place, staff was great too.

45924e0c-d3f3-4894-8948-ab6ebca68c34

While I can't justify paying $8+ (after tip and tax) for a simple PB sandwich more than once, I've since purchased a few of their jarred goods to support their business! I love that they also host some small comedy shows and such and the owner was super friendly!

03769832-9466-4a3a-a9ff-f8347f1c3309

Visited for carry-out for the first time a few weeks ago. I wanted ordered the Six Points Special because I wanted to try their peanut butter and jelly products straight up. I also ordered The King because it sounded amazing, and I thought it would showcase their PB&J sandwich making skills. As we know, the bread can make or break a sandwich. In this case the white bread I asked for on the Six Point Special broke it. I expected soft, fresh bread. It was firm and added a dry texture. I gave up on the sandwich after a few bites. On the positive side, the peanut butter and grape jelly tasted good. The King is served on bread "grilled" a panini press, which I liked. It is made with sliced bananas, their house-made peanut butter, and honey. Adding bacon is an option, and that was what I wanted, but they were out. Someone forgot to check bacon inventory over the weekend. My sandwich needed more honey or something to offset the dry bread and mouthfeel of the peanut butter. Maybe bacon would have helped a little. I think I will stick to making my own PB&J's, but I would be willing to use their nut butters and jellies when I do.

Discover Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli in Milwaukee, WI—delicious sandwiches in West Allis. Satisfy your cravings today with our tasty, unique menu options.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli in Milwaukee - Tasty Sandwiches

West Allis

Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli

Wisconsin

Explore the full menu at Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli in Milwaukee. Discover signature sandwiches, drinks & must-try items. Visit us at 6125 W Greenfield Ave.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli Menu – Food & Drinks in Milwaukee

Learn about Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli in Milwaukee. A cozy spot known for delicious sandwiches, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Located at 6125 W Greenfield Ave.

About Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli, Milwaukee

Opening hours for Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli, Milwaukee. Find opening hours for Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli, Milwaukee on 6125 W Greenfield Ave.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli Menu Overview

Signature Dishes

Beverages and Pairings

Dietary Options

Chef Recommendations

Experience the Menu at Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli

The Buzzards Nest

Z’s Bar

Oniomania