Nestled in the heart of Irvine's Quail Hill neighborhood, Johnny's Real New York Pizza is a local pizzeria chain that delivers authentic New York-style pizza pies in a retro and laid-back setting. If you're craving a classic, foldable, cheese-laden slice or a pepperoni pie reminiscent of the bustling pizzerias of NYC, this spot offers a nostalgic bite that transports you straight to the East Coast without leaving California.
The atmosphere at Johnny’s is a low-key, retro vibe that feels casual and inviting, making it perfect for a quick lunch, dinner with friends, or a casual night out. The place offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, ensuring there's a way for everyone to enjoy their signature pies. Outdoor seating is available for those who prefer to enjoy their pizza al fresco, and the establishment is wheelchair accessible, catering to all guests.
A standout feature is their Happy Hour special, which offers pizza slices and drinks at a great value before 5 PM — perfect for a casual early evening bite.
Johnny's menu features a variety of New York-style pizza slices including classic cheese, pepperoni, and specialty options with toppings like mushrooms. Regulars praise the cheese pizza as a must-try, along with perfectly sauced wings served with flavorful dips. While some visitors mention that pizza slices are sometimes served under heat lamps rather than freshly reheated, others appreciate the foldable, cheesy slices that meet the classic New York expectations.
The pizzeria serves beer and wine, making it a chill spot for casual dining. Plus, with free parking options including a lot and street parking, accessibility is convenient whether you’re driving or dropping by on foot.
The community sentiment around Johnny's Real New York Pizza is mixed. Many patrons love the authentic New York-style slices and the friendly, attentive service, especially highlighting the warm hospitality of the kitchen staff. However, some have noted inconsistencies in food quality and service, such as issues with reheating slices or unfamiliarity with NY pizza jargon. Despite these critiques, the pizzeria remains a valued local business and a go-to for those seeking a quick, casual pizza fix.
- What are the restaurant's operating hours? Sunday: 10:30 AM–7:00 PM; Monday–Thursday: 10:30 AM–8:00 PM; Friday–Saturday: 10:30 AM–9:00 PM.
- Is there outdoor seating available? Yes, the restaurant offers outdoor seating.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, delivery is available.
- Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, it is wheelchair accessible.
- Do they serve alcohol? Yes, the restaurant serves alcohol.
Johnny's Real New York Pizza has firmly established itself as a beloved spot in Irvine, California, by delivering the authentic taste of New York-style pizza to the West Coast. Since opening its third location in 2014 at the vibrant Quail Hill Shopping Center, this local pizzeria has been delighting residents and visitors alike with its traditional and specialty pizzas, complemented by a diverse menu including pastas, salads, and sandwiches.
At Johnny's, the focus is on replicating the classic New York slice experience — big, toasty, foldable, and incredibly cheesy. This pizzeria is a haven for pizza lovers craving that unmistakable New York crust and flavor right in the heart of Orange County. While some patrons note areas for improvement, such as reheating slices to perfection, the commitment to serving fresh, flavorful pies shines through in their extensive menu offerings.
Beyond the pizza itself, Johnny's Real New York Pizza is celebrated for its friendly and attentive staff, creating a welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit enjoyable. With options for dine-in, takeout, delivery, and even curbside pickup, the pizzeria meets the needs of busy locals and casual diners alike. Their offerings of beer and wine further enhance the dining experience, inviting guests to relax and savor their meal.
- Established in 2014 - Opened its third location in the Quail Hill Shopping Center, marking a significant expansion into Irvine.
- Menu variety - Offers classic and specialty pizzas, pastas, salads, and sandwiches to satisfy diverse tastes.
- Customer service - Known for polite, attentive staff who elevate the dining experience.
- Convenient service options - Dine-in, takeout, delivery, curbside pickup, and outdoor seating available to suit every preference.
at a glance
- Authentic New York-style pizza Friendly and attentive staff Variety of menu options including gluten-free and vegan choices Outdoor seating available Delivery and takeout services offered
- [List Item]
- Inconsistent food quality reported by some customers Limited operating hours on Sundays Some reviews mention issues with food temperature and preparation
- [List Item]
Families looking for a casual dining experience, students needing a quick meal, and pizza lovers craving authentic New York-style slices will find Johnny's a fitting choice.
Happy Hour specials are available for pizza slices and drinks before 5 PM. The restaurant offers both takeout and delivery options, making it convenient for those on the go.
Johnny's Real New York Pizza offers a blend of authentic flavors and a welcoming atmosphere. While there are some inconsistencies in food quality, the friendly staff and variety of options make it a worthwhile stop for pizza enthusiasts in Irvine.
Nestled in the vibrant Quail Hill neighborhood of Irvine, California, Johnny's Real New York Pizza offers a genuine taste of classic New York-style pizza right on Quail Hill Parkway. This local pizzeria chain captures the essence of New York with its foldable, toasty, and cheesy slices, making it a beloved spot for pizza lovers in Orange County. While the setting is unpretentious with a retro vibe, the welcoming atmosphere and straightforward menu make it ideal for those seeking a quick, satisfying slice or a casual dine-in experience.
Johnny's serves a variety of New York-style pizzas including classic pepperoni, cheese, and specialty slices like pepperoni with mushrooms. Customers rave about the cheese pizza, often described as the best in the area thanks to its melty cheese and perfectly balanced sauce. Wings are also a popular side, praised for their flavorful sauces that complement the pies perfectly. Though some slices are prepped under heat lamps for convenience, the kitchen is happy to reheat slices upon request to bring out that ideal crispiness and warmth—just like a true NY slice should be.
Whether you're craving a quick slice on the go or prefer to relax and soak in the ambiance, Johnny's Real New York Pizza has you covered. Their offerings include:
- Delivery – Order your favorite New York-style pizza and wings straight to your door with convenient delivery service.
- Takeout – Grab your meal to enjoy the authentic flavors of New York pizza in the comfort of your home.
- Dine-in – Experience the cozy, retro environment with friendly service and the option to enjoy your meal onsite.
- Outdoor seating – Savor your slice in the fresh Californian air with outdoor seating options available.
Johnny's goes beyond pizza by offering beer and wine, making it a great spot for casual evenings. The restaurant is kid-friendly and offers free parking options including a lot and street parking, making it accessible for families and groups. Payment is easy with credit, debit, and NFC options accepted, ensuring a smooth checkout experience. While live music isn't on the menu, the friendly staff and authentic flavors provide plenty of entertainment.
If you’re craving classic New York pizza in the heart of Irvine, Johnny’s offers a slice of the Big Apple with a local twist. It’s an excellent choice for fans of authentic NYC-style pies looking for a no-frills, family-owned pizzeria that prioritizes friendly service and genuine flavors. Whether you're a busy local grabbing a slice on the go or a foodie wanting to indulge in a cheesy, foldable pizza experience, Johnny's Real New York Pizza is a promising destination worth exploring.
