the four horsemen menu overview.
Nestled in the heart of Williamsburg, Brooklyn, The Four Horsemen offers a refined menu that celebrates fresh, seasonally driven ingredients with a New American twist. This cozy wine bar, inspired by Scandinavian and Japanese design, invites diners to savor beautifully crafted small plates alongside a thoughtfully curated selection of natural wines. With an atmosphere that balances warmth and elegance, each dish is designed to delight the senses and elevate your dining experience.
starters
Begin your culinary journey with an array of starters that showcase both innovative flavor combinations and comforting textures. The beef tartare offers a bold blend of finely chopped beef accented by pepitas and mild habanada peppers, served alongside crisp sesame crackers for a perfect bite. For a lighter option, the braised leek toast delivers tender leeks atop buttery herb bread, balancing earthiness and richness. Don't miss the gnocchi fritti, a delightful fried potato dumpling that is crispy on the outside and soft within. The cured egg yolk adds a nuanced touch with its delicate salt and sugar curing, making it a subtle yet memorable start. And for those who appreciate simplicity at its finest, the warm house bread, made from scratch with flour, water, yeast, and salt, is served fresh and comforting.
mains
The main courses at The Four Horsemen are a testament to refined, seasonally inspired cooking. The butter beans fra diavolo is a standout — tender butter beans bathed in a robust tomato sauce with perfectly balanced spices, delivering warmth and depth. For a timeless classic, the ham and cheese sandwich brings together savory ham and melting cheese nestled between fresh bread, elevated by quality ingredients. Seafood lovers will appreciate the yellowfin tuna dish, which highlights the tuna's natural flavor enhanced with fragrant olive oil, bright lemon, and fresh herbs, offering a light yet satisfying centerpiece.
desserts
Indulge your sweet tooth with rich, thoughtfully prepared desserts that provide a perfect finale. The sticky toffee pudding combines dates, flour, sugar, butter, and eggs into a moist, luscious treat that feels both comforting and luxurious. Meanwhile, the olive oil cake captivates with its moist crumb and subtle fruity notes from the olive oil, a refined dessert that pairs beautifully with a glass from the bar’s natural wine selection.
drinks
While The Four Horsemen is celebrated for its evocative menu, its wine list is equally exceptional. The bar features an impressive collection of natural wines, carefully selected to complement the menu’s flavors and elevate your dining experience. In addition to wine, the venue serves beer and coffee, making it an ideal spot for both casual gatherings and special occasions.
