Nestled in the heart of Grand Village Center North, Little Sicily Pizza is a beloved treasure for food lovers seeking an authentic taste of Chicago-style deep dish right in Surprise, AZ. This cozy mom-and-pop pizzeria masterfully crafts everything from extra thin crust pies to hearty Italian beef sandwiches, bringing a true slice of the Windy City to the Southwest. Whether you're craving a heavy, sauce-rich deep dish or a light, crispy thin crust, this spot is known for its fresh ingredients and family-friendly vibe that makes every visit feel like a warm gathering with loved ones.
Little Sicily Pizza is run by George, a Chicago native whose passion for authentic flavors shines in every dish. From the deep dish that’s "sooo worth it" with extra toppings to the Italian beef sandwiches served on Turano bread, the menu offers a rich variety for discerning palates. Guests rave about the fresh sauce and quality cheeses that meld perfectly with traditional toppings. The thin crust pizzas are described as "phenomenal," capturing the essence of Chicago’s pizzeria culture with every bite.
Visitors appreciate the intimate dining space that feels like a family gathering spot. While the indoor area is small, outdoor seating provides a lovely alternative under Arizona’s sunny skies. A standout feature is the BYOB policy, allowing guests to bring their own beer or wine without any corkage fee, making it perfect for casual lunches, hearty dinners, or catching up with friends over a shared pizza.
Freshness and quality are evident in every dish. From the Italian-style hot dogs to the tempting wings and desserts, Little Sicily Pizza delivers a well-rounded menu that caters to families and groups. The friendly, mom-and-pop atmosphere is often praised for making customers feel like part of the family, creating a loyal local following.
- Operating hours: Open Tuesday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, with extended hours until 9:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. Closed Sundays and Mondays.
- BYOB Policy: Bring your own beer or wine to complement your meal with no corkage fee.
- Delivery and Takeout: Convenient delivery options including no-contact delivery, as well as takeout for enjoying your pizza at home.
- Outdoor seating: Enjoy your meal in the fresh Arizona air with available outdoor seating.
- Reservations: Calling ahead is recommended due to the small, popular space especially during peak hours.
- What are the operating hours of Little Sicily Pizza? Little Sicily Pizza operates Tuesday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday until 9:00 PM. The restaurant is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
- Is Little Sicily Pizza a BYOB establishment? Yes, Little Sicily Pizza is a BYOB (Bring Your Own Beverage) restaurant, allowing guests to bring their own drinks to enjoy with their meal.
- Does Little Sicily Pizza offer delivery services? Yes, Little Sicily Pizza provides delivery services, including no-contact delivery options for customer convenience.
- Is there outdoor seating available at Little Sicily Pizza? Yes, Little Sicily Pizza offers outdoor seating for guests who prefer to dine outside.
- Does Little Sicily Pizza accept reservations? It is recommended to call ahead to check for availability, as the restaurant is small and can get busy during peak hours.
The community sentiment around Little Sicily Pizza is overwhelmingly positive. Locals and visitors alike celebrate the restaurant for its authentic Chicago-style offerings and its genuine, family-oriented atmosphere. Patrons frequently highlight the fresh, flavorful food and the warm, welcoming environment that makes each meal memorable. The BYOB policy and intimate setting create a unique, cozy dining experience cherished by many in Surprise, Arizona.
Nestled in the heart of Surprise, Arizona, Little Sicily Pizza has established itself as a beloved family-owned restaurant since its inception in 2014. Renowned for its authentic Chicago-style pizzas, the eatery quickly became a go-to destination for food lovers seeking genuine Italian-American flavors in a warm and welcoming environment.
Little Sicily Pizza opened its doors in 2014 with a mission to bring the rich culinary tradition of Chicago-style deep-dish pizza to the Surprise community. This unique style, characterized by its buttery crust, generous cheese layers, and robust tomato sauce, quickly earned the restaurant a loyal following. Its dedication to quality ingredients and authentic preparation methods set it apart in the local dining scene.
By 2016, Little Sicily Pizza enhanced the dining experience by introducing a BYOB (Bring Your Own Beverage) policy, allowing patrons to complement their meals with their favorite drinks. This move fostered a cozy, community-centric atmosphere, encouraging guests to unwind and savor their meals.
Two years later, in 2018, the menu expanded further to include a selection of Italian sandwiches, such as the popular Italian Beef Sandwich and hearty Meatball Sandwich. These additions complemented the restaurant's pizza offerings and showcased its commitment to delivering a broad spectrum of authentic Italian flavors.
The year 2020 brought unprecedented challenges with the COVID-19 pandemic. Demonstrating agility and customer care, Little Sicily Pizza swiftly implemented no-contact delivery services, ensuring the safety of its patrons while continuing to bring its signature dishes to doorsteps throughout the region.
By 2022, Little Sicily Pizza celebrated its 8th anniversary, a testament to its enduring popularity and the deep roots it has planted within the Surprise community. Throughout its history, the restaurant has maintained a steadfast focus on authentic Italian cuisine, quality ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes guests feel like family.
- Authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza that captures the essence of Italian-American culinary tradition.
- BYOB dining experience that creates a cozy and personalized atmosphere for guests.
- Selection of Italian sandwiches and pasta dishes that offer a delicious variety beyond pizza.
- Commitment to community and customer safety demonstrated by adopting no-contact delivery during the pandemic.
Located at 18795 N Reems Rd in Surprise, Arizona, Little Sicily Pizza offers a taste of authentic Chicago-style pizza in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. This lively BYOB establishment is known for its thin-crust pies, wings, and a variety of Italian sandwiches, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors. With a focus on quality ingredients and a family-friendly vibe, Little Sicily Pizza has become a beloved spot in the Grand Village Center North neighborhood.
- Authentic Chicago-style pizza
- Friendly and attentive service
- BYOB policy
- Cozy and family-friendly atmosphere
- Variety of Italian sandwiches
- Outdoor seating available
- Limited seating capacity
- No reservations accepted
- Small dining area
Little Sicily Pizza is perfect for families, casual dining with friends, or a cozy date night. The BYOB policy allows guests to bring their favorite drinks, enhancing the experience. Whether you're craving a hearty deep-dish pizza or a delicious Italian sandwich, this spot caters to all appetites.
- Order ahead, especially on weekends, to avoid long waits.
- Parking is available in the lot and on the street.
- The restaurant is small, so be prepared for a cozy dining experience.
Little Sicily Pizza stands out as a delightful spot for pizza lovers in Surprise, AZ. With its authentic Chicago-style offerings and a welcoming atmosphere, it captures the essence of a true family-run restaurant. While it may have some limitations in seating and reservations, the quality of food and service makes it a worthwhile visit. Whether you're dining in or taking out, this restaurant is sure to satisfy your cravings for delicious Italian cuisine.
Nestled at 18795 North Reems Road, Surprise, Little Sicily Pizza is a cozy, family-run restaurant where the spirit of Chicago pizza shines bright in Arizona’s West Valley. This is the place to indulge in deep-dish masterpieces, ultra-thin crust marvels, and classic Italian favorites that bring the Windy City’s flavors straight to your table.
Little Sicily is famous for its spot-on Chicago-style deep dish pizza, known for its thick, buttery crust loaded with rich tomato sauce and generous toppings. If you prefer something lighter, George, the Chicago-born owner, crafts phenomenal thin crust pizzas that boast crisp edges and fresh ingredients. Beyond pizza, the menu features Italian beef sandwiches on Turano bread, Chicago-style hot dogs, and hearty pasta dishes that capture the essence of Italian-American comfort food.
Expect a warm, intimate dining experience in a space filled with nostalgic memorabilia that celebrates the rich heritage of Chicago’s pizza scene. This mom and pop style restaurant makes every guest feel like family. While the indoor seating area is small and cozy, there is also outdoor seating available to savor your meal under the Arizona sky.
Little Sicily Pizza offers several ways to enjoy your favorite dishes, whether you’re dining in or on the go. Take advantage of:
- Outdoor seating to enjoy your meal in the fresh Arizona air.
- No-contact delivery providing a safe and convenient way to get your pizza fix delivered right to your door.
- Takeout options for those on the move—just order ahead and swing by to pick up your meal.
- Dine-in experience in a friendly setting where you can savor every bite.
- BYOB Policy Bring your own beer or wine and enjoy your favorite drinks with no corkage fee.
- Family-friendly A welcoming spot for kids and groups, perfect for casual meals and celebrations.
- Payment Options Accepts debit, credit cards, and contactless NFC payments for convenient checkout.
