Overview of the menu
Little Sicily Pizza in Surprise, Arizona, offers a delightful dive into authentic Chicago-style cuisine. This cozy, BYOB establishment specializes in hearty deep-dish pizzas, thin-crust options, and classic Italian sandwiches, all served in a warm, nostalgic atmosphere adorned with memorabilia. The culinary philosophy here emphasizes traditional recipes and fresh ingredients, ensuring every bite is a taste of home.
Signature dishes
- Chicago Deep Dish Pizza with Mushrooms: A rich blend of sausage, pepperoni, ham, and mushrooms, baked to perfection.
- Thin Crust Half Sausage Half Special: A delightful combination of sausage and special toppings on a crispy base.
- Italian Beef Sandwich: Juicy beef served with au jus on a toasted bun, a true Chicago classic.
Beverages and pairings
At Little Sicily, guests are encouraged to bring their own beverages, with no corkage fee, making it an ideal spot for enjoying a favorite wine or beer alongside the delicious pizzas. The pairing of a robust red wine with the deep-dish pizza enhances the flavors, while a light beer complements the thin-crust options perfectly.
Dietary options
Little Sicily Pizza caters to various dietary needs, offering vegetarian options and the possibility to customize pizzas to avoid allergens. While gluten-free options are limited, the staff is accommodating and willing to assist with dietary requests.
Chef recommendations
For a truly authentic experience, the Chef recommends the Chicago Deep Dish Pizza with Mushrooms, especially during the cooler months when comfort food is a must. The Italian Beef Sandwich is also a standout, perfect for lunch or a quick bite.
Experience the menu
Join us at Little Sicily Pizza in Surprise, Arizona, for a memorable dining experience filled with authentic flavors and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're indulging in a deep-dish pizza or savoring an Italian sandwich, every meal is crafted with care and passion.





