Download

Twin Falls

Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls has received a range of reviews. Some patrons praise the crispy crust and fresh toppings, while others have concerns about service speed and food quality. The establishment offers a variety of menu items, including specialty pizzas, calzones, and salads, catering to diverse tastes.

Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls Idaho: A Slice of Authentic New York Flavor in the Magic Valley Valley's Heart.

Nestled in the charming town of Twin Falls, Idaho, Lucy's New York Style Pizza offers a genuine taste of New York's iconic thin-crust pizza tradition. This cozy eatery at 210 2nd Avenue South invites food lovers and locals alike to indulge in perfectly crispy yet chewy crusts, fresh toppings, and a vibrant atmosphere that captures the essence of classic New York pizzerias.

An authentic new york style pizza experience

At Lucy's, the spotlight shines on their signature thin-crust pizzas that boast a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Whether you crave a hearty meaty half or a zest-packed vegetarian slice, each pizza is crafted with quality ingredients and care. Beyond pizza, the menu includes savory calzones, fresh subs, crisp salads, and delightful desserts, ensuring something for every palate.

Enjoy a welcoming atmosphere and versatile dining options

Lucy's New York Style Pizza is more than just great food — it's an inviting spot where friends and families gather. With dine-in seating, including outdoor options perfect for sunny Idaho days, and convenient takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup services, Lucy's meets every dining preference. The friendly staff and cozy setting make it a top choice for lunch or dinner in Twin Falls.

Local diners praise Lucy's for delivering authentic New York flavors with a welcoming vibe and attentive service. The variety of toppings and quality of ingredients consistently earn compliments. However, some guests have mentioned occasional inconsistencies with service speed and food temperature, indicating areas for future improvement.

 who create a cozy and inviting dining environment.

 from classic meats to creative vegetarian options.

 including dine-in, delivery, takeout, and curbside pickup.

Frequently asked questions about lucy's new york style pizza

What are the operating hours of Lucy's New York Style Pizza?

 Lucy's is open Monday through Saturday from 10:30 AM to 9:30 PM and closed on Sundays.

 Yes, gluten-free crust options are available for pizzas.

 Yes, customers can enjoy outdoor seating at the Twin Falls location.

 Yes, delivery services are offered for local convenience.

 Yes, major credit cards including Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover are accepted.

North America

United States

Lucy's New York Style Pizza, located at 210 2nd Ave S in Twin Falls, Idaho, is a beloved local restaurant known for its delicious thin-crust pizza. This eatery offers a cozy atmosphere perfect for families and pizza lovers alike. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, it's a convenient choice for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner, Lucy's has something to satisfy your appetite.

At Lucy's, the menu features a variety of pizza options, calzones, subs, and fresh salads, all made with quality ingredients. Highlights include:

Thin-crust pizza with a variety of toppings.

Calzones and subs for those looking for something different.

Fresh salads made with seasonal ingredients.

Situated in the heart of Twin Falls, Lucy's New York Style Pizza is conveniently located near several local attractions. Visitors can explore the stunning Shoshone Falls, known as the "Niagara of the West," or take a stroll along the scenic Snake River Canyon. The restaurant is also close to the Twin Falls County Historical Museum, making it an ideal stop for those looking to enjoy a meal after sightseeing.

Lucy's offers a range of amenities to enhance your dining experience, including:

Outdoor seating for enjoying the fresh air.

Live music events to enhance your dining experience.

Unassuming local chain eatery serving up thin-crust pizza, plus calzones, subs & salads.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmMDh1ZjN3RRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ1wwMtFejrFQRjabca4vTZPw/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmMDh1ZjN3RRAB

This was hands down the worst pizza I've ever had. The cheese pizza was a soggy, greasy mess with way too much cheese and what looked like burnt ashes on it. It was completely inedible. The whole experience was incredibly unprofessional. I will not be ordering from here again.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUN2NjZqUFR3EAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ1wwMtFejrFQRjabca4vTZPw/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUN2NjZqUFR3EAE

I got my order delivered yesterday (12/13) and was incredibly disappointed. The meat pizza side on half and half pizza was completely burnt, almost to the point of being inedible. The crust was hard as a rock and the cheese was completely blackened. I called the restaurant to inform and they offered a measly discount on my next order.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNyMmE3RHNBRRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ1wwMtFejrFQRjabca4vTZPw/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNyMmE3RHNBRRAB

I can start with my own mistake, I ordered online from the wrong location. Note, Idaho Falls is not near Twin Falls, ID! When I arrive at the Lucy’s in Twin Falls I checked on my order only to find out I had ordered from one of the Idaho Falls locations. The crew at the Twin Falls location told me not to worry, they would call the Idaho Falls location and cancel my order and promptly started my order at their location. The pizza was ready about as fast as you could expect, AND, they wouldn’t charge me for my mistake. This Twin Falls location is located in the Second South Market with a very nice bar conveniently located across the way while you wait!!! Friendly attentive staff, and great pizza! Highly recommend! I ordered the 18” 1/2&1/2 1/2 Meaty, 1/2 Zestpian.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNIOGVYZldnEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ1wwMtFejrFQRjabca4vTZPw/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNIOGVYZldnEAE

29 minutes for 2 slices of 4.00 sloppy soggy pizza …..that is a super neat way to run a business.  New York style pizza huh ? Don’t count on it I lived in Maryland for 30 years went to New York weekly.  This is hot can sauce trash of a pizza.  The flys are a nice touch

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURYNFBQT2RREAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ1wwMtFejrFQRjabca4vTZPw/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURYNFBQT2RREAE

I had the absolute pleasure of dining at Lucy's, and it was hands down the best pizza I've had in a long time! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and light and chewy on the inside. Every topping was fresh and flavorful, and the balance of sauce to cheese was just right. The service was quick and friendly, and the cozy atmosphere just added to the experience. If you’re a pizza lover, this place is a must-try. I’ll definitely be back!

Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls – Best Thin-Crust!

Lucy's New York Style Pizza was established in 2009, aiming to bring authentic New York-style pizza to small towns. They emphasize fresh, hand-made dough and sauces, with all ingredients prepared in-house.

History of Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls Idaho 

Established in 2009, Lucy's New York Style Pizza has carved out a special place in the Twin Falls food scene by bringing authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza to the heart of Idaho. This local gem has been delighting pizza lovers for over a decade with its commitment to fresh, hand-tossed dough and house-made sauces that evoke the classic flavors of the Big Apple.

From its inception, Lucy's has focused on delivering an inviting and casual dining experience that goes beyond just pizza. Alongside their signature pies, they offer a diverse menu featuring calzones, subs, fresh salads, and indulgent desserts, catering to a wide range of tastes and preferences. This variety makes Lucy's a popular spot for families, friends, and solo diners seeking quality comfort food.

Over the years, Lucy's New York Style Pizza has become more than just a restaurant; it has established itself as a beloved community fixture in Twin Falls. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and attentive service create a neighborhood vibe that keeps patrons coming back. Whether dining in, taking out, or enjoying delivery, customers appreciate the consistent quality and local charm.

In 2009, Lucy's New York Style Pizza opened its doors in Twin Falls, introducing authentic New York thin-crust pizza to the area.

Lucy’s serves a variety of specialty pizzas, calzones, subs, and fresh salads, offering more than just the traditional pizza fare.

Committed to hand-tossed dough and house-made sauces, Lucy's maintains the true essence of New York pizza craftsmanship.

Lucy's New York Style Pizza offers more than just a meal — it’s a destination for pizza aficionados and casual diners alike. The restaurant's location in downtown Twin Falls provides convenient access with ample parking and outdoor seating options. Inside, guests find a cozy, family-friendly environment complemented by attentive service. The menu is thoughtfully crafted to pair well with their selection of beer and desserts, making it a great spot for lunch or dinner outings.

Whether you’re seeking the classic taste of New York pizza or a welcoming local atmosphere in Twin Falls, Lucy’s stands out as a delicious and authentic dining option since 2009.

Lucy's New York Style Pizza is an unassuming local chain eatery in Twin Falls, Idaho, serving up delicious thin-crust pizza, calzones, subs, and salads. The warm atmosphere and quality ingredients make it a must-visit for pizza lovers.

Lucy's New York Style Pizza

Authentic New York-style pizza with a variety of toppings and specialty pies, along with calzones, salads, and more.

Breadsticks

Cheesesticks

Firesticks

Fried Mutz

Wings (10)

Boneless Wings (10)

Meatball

Pickles and Olives

Half Caprese Salad

Full Caprese Salad

Antipasto Salad

House Salad

Family Salad

Flavor of the Month Slice

Roni Slice

Cheese Slice

Margherita Slice

12" Build Your Own Pizza

12" Half&Half Specialty Pizza

12" Meaty Pizza

12" Supreme Pizza

12" Margherita Pizza

12" Zestpian Pizza

12" CCB Pizza

12" Pacific Pizza

12" Veggie Pizza

12" BBQ Pizza

12" Buffalo Pizza

12" Blaise Pizza

12" Zim Pizza

12" BLT Pizza

12" Pizzle Pizza

12" Game Changer Pizza

15" Build Your Own Pizza

15" Half&Half Specialty Pizza

15" Meaty Pizza

15" Supreme Pizza

15" Margherita Pizza

15" Zestpian Pizza

15" CCB Pizza

15" Pacific Pizza

15" Veggie Pizza

15" BBQ Pizza

15" Buffalo Pizza

15" Blaise Pizza

15" Zim Pizza

15" BLT Pizza

15" Pizzle Pizza

15" Game Changer Pizza

18" Build Your Own Pizza

18" Half&Half Specialty Pizza

18" Meaty Pizza

18" Supreme Pizza

18" Margherita Pizza

18" Zestpian Pizza

18" CCB Pizza

18" Pacific Pizza

18" Veggie Pizza

18" BBQ Pizza

18" Buffalo Pizza

18" Blaise Pizza

18" Zim Pizza

18" BLT Pizza

18" Pizzle Pizza

18" Game Changer Pizza

GF Build Your Own Pizza

GF Half&Half Specialty Pizza

GF Meaty Pizza

GF Supreme Pizza

GF Margherita Pizza

GF Zestpian Pizza

GF CCB Pizza

GF Pacific Pizza

GF Veggie Pizza

Xtras

Lucy's New York Style Pizza Menu

Lucy's New York Style Pizza Menu Overview - Twin Falls Idaho's Authentic Thin-Crust Pizzeria Experience.

At Lucy's New York Style Pizza, located in the heart of Twin Falls, Idaho, the menu offers an enticing selection of authentic New York-style pizzas, complemented by delicious starters, hearty calzones, fresh salads, and satisfying desserts. Whether you're dining in, ordering takeout, or enjoying delivery, each dish features high-quality, flavorful ingredients crafted to deliver a true taste of New York.

Begin your meal with classic favorites like the golden Breadsticks brushed with garlic butter and seasoned to perfection, served alongside a house-made marinara for dipping. For cheese lovers, the Cheesesticks offer melted mozzarella layered over garlic butter and seasonings, paired with that same rich marinara. If you crave a kick, try the Firesticks, tossed in spicy buffalo sauce with jalapeños and cheese for a fiery start.

Fried Mutz - crispy breaded whole milk cheese served with marinara.

Wings (10) and Boneless Wings (10) - tender chicken wings and breaded chunks available in buffalo, sweet chili, honey garlic, or BBQ sauce, served with ranch or blue cheese.

Meatball - a generous 10-ounce meatball smothered in house-made marinara for a rich and satisfying bite.

Pickles and Olives - tangy dill pickle spears paired with marinated olives for a light and briny nibble.

Salads - fresh options include Half or Full Caprese with creamy mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil dressed in olive oil and seasoning, the Antipasto Salad mixing greens with a medley of meats and vegetables, the classic House Salad, and a larger Family Salad perfect for sharing.

Lucy's signature thin-crust pizzas come in 12, 15, and 18-inch sizes, with a variety of classic and inventive toppings. Build your own pizza with luscious cheese and zesty red sauce, or select from crowd-pleasers like the Meaty Pizza loaded with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon, or the Supreme featuring peppers, onions, olives, mushrooms, and pepperoni.

Margherita Pizza - topped with fresh tomatoes and fragrant basil for a light, classic flavor.

Zestpian Pizza - a bold blend featuring smokey ranch sauce, pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple, and jalapeños.

CCB Pizza - creamy white sauce topped with tender chicken and crispy bacon.

Pacific Pizza - ham and pineapple combine for a classic Hawaiian-style pie.

Veggie Pizza - a hearty vegetarian option with artichokes, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.

For those who prefer something different, Lucy’s offers a variety of calzones, from the Small to Large sizes, filled with mozzarella, ricotta, and your choice of toppings. Options include Meaty, Supreme, Margherita, Zestpian, CCB, BLT, Pizzle, Game Changer, and Paddy's Boy, ensuring every palate is satisfied. Gluten-free crust is available to accommodate dietary needs.

Desserts and drinks rounding out the meal

Lucy's New York Style Pizza also offers delectable desserts to complete your dining experience, alongside a well-stocked bar serving beer to pair perfectly with your meal. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make Lucy's a local favorite for lunch and dinner alike, with convenient curbside pickup, free parking, and outdoor seating options.

Savor authentic NY-style pizza at Lucy's in Twin Falls! Fresh ingredients, unique flavors—your perfect dining stop. Discover deliciousness today!

Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls, ID

Twin Falls County

Enjoy a sit-down meal in a family-friendly environment.

Dine-in

Takeout

Have your meal delivered to your doorstep.

Delivery

Conveniently place orders through their website.

Online Ordering

lucy's new york style pizza twin falls idaho dining experience overview 

Nestled in the heart of Twin Falls, Idaho, Lucy's New York Style Pizza offers an inviting spot for pizza lovers craving authentic thin-crust slices with a local twist. Located conveniently at 210 2nd Avenue South, this unassuming eatery serves up a variety of tempting options including calzones, subs, salads, and of course, New York-style pizza that aims to impress with a perfectly crispy yet tender crust.

Whether you prefer to dine in or grab a quick takeout, Lucy's caters to all styles. Their comfortable indoor seating provides a cozy space to enjoy your meal, while outdoor seating options let you savor your pizza in the fresh Twin Falls air on pleasant days. For those on the go, curbside pickup adds convenience, and their reliable delivery service offers safe, contactless options right to your doorstep.

Lucy's prides itself on crafting thin-crust pizzas that balance a light, crispy exterior with just the right amount of chewiness inside. Their menu features classic combinations like meaty and zestpian halves, as well as fresh salads and hearty subs. Guests appreciate the fresh toppings and flavorful sauce that complement the cheese perfectly, aiming to deliver a taste reminiscent of authentic New York pizza but with local charm.

 are a hallmark of Lucy's, ensuring guests feel welcome whether dining in or ordering online. The restaurant offers amenities including clean restrooms and accommodates families with children. Parking is stress-free with free lot and street parking nearby, and payment is easy with credit, debit, and NFC options accepted.

 – cozy indoor seating for relaxed meals.

 – enjoy your pizza outside on sunny Twin Falls days.

 – quick and convenient options for busy days.

 – enjoy fresh pizza delivered safely to your home.

Lucy's New York Style Pizza is perfect for families and groups looking for a casual dining experience in Twin Falls. While the restaurant does not serve breakfast or coffee, it offers a full lunch and dinner menu along with desserts to satisfy your sweet tooth. The lively atmosphere is sometimes enhanced by live music, making it a great spot to unwind after exploring the city.

 Arrive early or call ahead during peak hours to enjoy the vibrant Second South Market neighborhood and its nearby bar options while you wait for your delicious New York-style pizza.

Idaho

Join us at Lucy's Pizza in Twin Falls for authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza made with fresh ingredients. Dine in or order delivery!

Lucy's New York Style Pizza - Twin Falls Gem

Savor the unique flavors of Lucy's New York Style Pizza! Enjoy outdoor seating and family-friendly dining in Twin Falls. Visit us today!

Explore Twin Falls: Best Pizza at Lucy's!

Discover dining tips, menu highlights, and more about Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls. A must-visit for pizza lovers!

Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls – Best Thin-Crust!

Dining & Culinary Delights

Location & Nearby Attractions

Amenities & Activities