Lucy's New York Style Pizza Menu Overview - Twin Falls Idaho's Authentic Thin-Crust Pizzeria Experience.
At Lucy's New York Style Pizza, located in the heart of Twin Falls, Idaho, the menu offers an enticing selection of authentic New York-style pizzas, complemented by delicious starters, hearty calzones, fresh salads, and satisfying desserts. Whether you're dining in, ordering takeout, or enjoying delivery, each dish features high-quality, flavorful ingredients crafted to deliver a true taste of New York.
Starters to whet your appetite
Begin your meal with classic favorites like the golden Breadsticks brushed with garlic butter and seasoned to perfection, served alongside a house-made marinara for dipping. For cheese lovers, the Cheesesticks offer melted mozzarella layered over garlic butter and seasonings, paired with that same rich marinara. If you crave a kick, try the Firesticks, tossed in spicy buffalo sauce with jalapeños and cheese for a fiery start.
- Fried Mutz - crispy breaded whole milk cheese served with marinara.
- Wings (10) and Boneless Wings (10) - tender chicken wings and breaded chunks available in buffalo, sweet chili, honey garlic, or BBQ sauce, served with ranch or blue cheese.
- Meatball - a generous 10-ounce meatball smothered in house-made marinara for a rich and satisfying bite.
- Pickles and Olives - tangy dill pickle spears paired with marinated olives for a light and briny nibble.
- Salads - fresh options include Half or Full Caprese with creamy mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil dressed in olive oil and seasoning, the Antipasto Salad mixing greens with a medley of meats and vegetables, the classic House Salad, and a larger Family Salad perfect for sharing.
Mains that define New York style pizza
Lucy's signature thin-crust pizzas come in 12, 15, and 18-inch sizes, with a variety of classic and inventive toppings. Build your own pizza with luscious cheese and zesty red sauce, or select from crowd-pleasers like the Meaty Pizza loaded with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon, or the Supreme featuring peppers, onions, olives, mushrooms, and pepperoni.
- Margherita Pizza - topped with fresh tomatoes and fragrant basil for a light, classic flavor.
- Zestpian Pizza - a bold blend featuring smokey ranch sauce, pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple, and jalapeños.
- CCB Pizza - creamy white sauce topped with tender chicken and crispy bacon.
- Pacific Pizza - ham and pineapple combine for a classic Hawaiian-style pie.
- Veggie Pizza - a hearty vegetarian option with artichokes, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
For those who prefer something different, Lucy’s offers a variety of calzones, from the Small to Large sizes, filled with mozzarella, ricotta, and your choice of toppings. Options include Meaty, Supreme, Margherita, Zestpian, CCB, BLT, Pizzle, Game Changer, and Paddy's Boy, ensuring every palate is satisfied. Gluten-free crust is available to accommodate dietary needs.
Desserts and drinks rounding out the meal
Lucy's New York Style Pizza also offers delectable desserts to complete your dining experience, alongside a well-stocked bar serving beer to pair perfectly with your meal. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make Lucy's a local favorite for lunch and dinner alike, with convenient curbside pickup, free parking, and outdoor seating options.
