Patsy's Pizzeria menu overview

Discover the authentic taste of Italian-American cuisine at Patsy's Pizzeria, a historic eatery located in the heart of Harlem, New York. Known for its legendary coal-fired pizzas, Patsy's also offers a rich variety of traditional Italian dishes that promise a flavorful dining experience in a warm, old-school atmosphere.

starters

Begin your meal with a selection of fresh and vibrant starters that include the classic Bruschetta featuring chopped fresh tomato salad on Italian bread, and the Caprese with mozzarella, vine-ripened tomatoes, roasted peppers, basil pesto, and extra virgin olive oil. For seafood lovers, the Grilled Octopus served with fingerling potatoes and chipotle aioli, or the Salmon Tartar with cucumber, avocado, capers, onions, and citrus soy sauce deliver distinctive flavors. The Baked Clams and Spicy Rock Shrimp bring a savory touch, while the Mixed Grill Veggies and various salads like the Insalata Siciliana and Burrata & Prosciutto Di Parma Salad offer fresh, garden-inspired taste sensations.

mains

The mains menu spotlights Patsy's signature coal oven pizzas, including the Original Coal Oven Pizza with tomato sauce and grated mozzarella, the fresh and aromatic Margherita Pizza topped with fresh mozzarella and basil, and the hearty Patsy's Pizzeria Special combining fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, romano cheese, and fresh garlic. Beyond pizza, indulge in classic pasta dishes such as Penne alla Vodka with reduced heavy cream, marinara, and romano cheese; Fettuccine Alfredo rich with cream and romano; and the savory Bucatini Carbonara loaded with bacon, wild mushrooms, and cream sauce. Chicken lovers can savor dishes like Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Francese, and Chicken Marsala, each prepared with traditional ingredients like marinara, lemon butter, marsala wine, and mushrooms. Seafood offerings include Linguine Alla Vongole, Linguine Fra Diavolo ai Frutti di Mare bursting with calamari, scallops, shrimp, and clams in a spicy tomato sauce, and the Grilled Mediterranean Branzino with heirloom tomato and cherry vinaigrette. Vegetarian options such as Spaghetti di Grano Duro con i Vegetali and Gemelli Arugula e' Pollo (with chicken option) ensure something delightful for everyone.

desserts

Complete your meal with traditional Italian desserts that perfectly balance sweetness and texture. Indulge in the creamy Cannoli with delicate pastry dough and sweet filling, or the decadent Tartufo featuring vanilla and chocolate gelato with cherry and sliced almonds. The classic Tiramisu offers a luscious blend of ladyfingers and mascarpone cream dusted with cocoa powder, while the New York Style Cheesecake is topped with strawberry glaze and fresh strawberries. Other tempting sweets include the Black Forest Cake, Limoncello Cake with lemon mascarpone cream, refreshing Gelato, Passion Fruit Sorbet, and light Profiteroles filled with cream.

drinks and specials

Patsy's Pizzeria offers a range of drinks to complement your meal, including classic cocktails, a good wine list, and beer selections. The restaurant’s cash-only policy and cozy, old-school pizza parlor vibe add to the authentic New York experience. Specials such as the Clam Pie with chopped clams, romano, garlic, and olive oil, and the Omar pizza topped with prosciutto, arugula, and balsamic vinaigrette highlight Patsy’s creativity beyond the classics. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, guests are guaranteed generous portions crafted from high-quality ingredients that have delighted patrons since 1933.

What makes Patsy's pizza unique? Patsy's specializes in thin crust coal oven pizza that is light, flavorful, and perfectly crisp without flop.
Are there vegetarian options available? Yes, the menu includes vegetarian-friendly dishes such as Margherita Pizza, Spaghetti di Grano Duro con i Vegetali and various mixed vegetable starters.
Does Patsy's accept credit cards? Patsy's Pizzeria operates on a cash-only basis, adding to its classic neighborhood charm.

4.2

2287 1st Ave., New York, NY 10035, USA

(212) 534-9783

Open Now - Closing 10:00 PM

Monday

11:00–22:00

Tuesday

11:00–22:00

Wednesday

11:00–22:00

Thursday

11:00–23:00