Nestled in the vibrant College Hill neighborhood of Greensboro, North Carolina, New York Pizza stands out as a beloved hotspot for fans of authentic Italian street food and classic New York–style pies. Located at 337 Tate Street, this cozy pizzeria doubles as a laid-back bar and a lively music venue, offering an irresistible blend of great food, drinks, and community spirit that keeps patrons coming back again and again.
New York Pizza is celebrated for its next-level stromboli, stuffed with a perfect balance of melted cheese, thinly sliced boudin blanc-style sausage, spicy pepperoni, and a crust that's both sweet and salty. But the menu doesn't stop there — from hand-tossed pizza pies and classic chicken parmigiana to crispy arancini and flavorful subs, every dish is crafted with quality ingredients and an authentic Italian flair. Vegetarian options are thoughtfully available, ensuring that everyone can find something delicious to savor.
While you wait for your order, enjoy a cold Red Oak beer on tap or one of the daily drink specials in their welcoming bar, known for its friendly bartenders who keep the good vibes flowing evenly throughout the room. Whether you're gathering with friends for a casual meal or unwinding after a long day, the warm, inviting atmosphere combined with live music events and occasional bar trivia makes New York Pizza a lively neighborhood gem.
- Dine-in with comfortable seating and a cozy bar area that transforms into a nighttime venue featuring live bands and DJs.
- Takeout, delivery and curbside pickup available for maximum convenience.
- Outdoor seating lets you soak up the lively College Hill vibe while enjoying your meal.
- Wheelchair accessibility ensures everyone can join in the fun.
- Convenient payment options including credit, debit, and NFC technology.
- What are the restaurant's operating hours? Monday: 11:30 AM – 2:00 AM, Tuesday: Closed, Wednesday to Friday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 AM, Saturday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM, Sunday: 1:00 PM – 12:00 AM.
- Is there outdoor seating available? Yes, guests can enjoy outdoor seating in a lively neighborhood setting.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, New York Pizza provides delivery for enjoying their delicious menu at home.
- Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, it is fully accessible including entrance and seating areas.
- Do they accept reservations? Yes, reservations are welcomed, especially for busy times and weekends.
Visitors rave about New York Pizza’s "next-level" stromboli, describing it as possibly the best they've ever tasted, with perfectly balanced flavors and a crispy, chewy crust. The friendly, attentive service at both the order window and the bar enhances the dining experience, creating a warm atmosphere where customers can enjoy a beer, engage in lively bar trivia, or listen to live music. Many patrons consider it their go-to spot for authentic Italian street food and outstanding pizza, praising the quality and value that sets it apart from other pizzerias in Greensboro.
Experience New York Pizza for yourself and indulge in a true taste of Italy right in the heart of Greensboro, complete with an inviting community vibe and delicious food that keeps everyone coming back for more.
Nestled in the lively College Hill neighborhood of Greensboro, New York Pizza has been a beloved culinary landmark since its inception. For over 30 years, it has brought the unmistakable flavors of authentic New York-style pizza to North Carolina, becoming a go-to destination for pizza aficionados and casual diners alike.
1990 - New York Pizza was established in Greensboro, marking the beginning of a new chapter for Italian cuisine in the area. From day one, the focus was on delivering that classic New York pizza experience, characterized by hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, and bold flavors.
2000 - The restaurant earned a high sanitation grade, cementing its reputation as a clean and trustworthy establishment. This milestone helped make New York Pizza a local favorite, attracting loyal customers who appreciated not only the taste but also the quality and hygiene.
2015 - A pivotal ownership change sparked an era of revitalization for New York Pizza. The new management invested in elevating food quality and enhancing customer service, which translated into higher ratings and a renewed buzz in the community.
2020 - Continuing its legacy as a community staple, New York Pizza remained a popular spot for locals and visitors. Its combination of authentic New York flavors, inviting atmosphere, and stellar service keeps guests coming back time and time again.
With a rich history rooted in authenticity and quality, New York Pizza offers more than just a meal — it delivers an experience. From their carefully crafted dough to their generous toppings, each pizza reflects decades of perfected tradition. The restaurant’s commitment to maintaining high sanitation standards and an inviting environment has earned it a cherished spot in Greensboro's culinary scene.
- Established legacy - Over 30 years of serving authentic New York-style pizza in Greensboro.
- Hygiene excellence - Known for achieving and maintaining high sanitation grades, ensuring a safe dining experience.
- Quality improvements - Ownership changes in 2015 elevated food quality and customer satisfaction.
- Community favorite - A beloved spot for locals and university students, known for its warm atmosphere and delicious menu.
Located at 337 Tate St, Greensboro, NC, New York Pizza offers a cozy bar setting that transforms into a lively venue with live music on weekends. This straightforward pizzeria is known for its authentic New York-style pizza and a variety of Italian street food, making it a popular choice among locals and visitors alike.
With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, it’s an ideal spot for casual dining or grabbing a drink while waiting for your food. The establishment is pet-friendly and wheelchair accessible, catering to a diverse clientele.
Whether you're in the mood for pizza, stromboli, or a refreshing beer, New York Pizza has something for everyone.
The establishment's editorial summary highlights its straightforward approach to pizzeria dining, offering a cozy bar setting that morphs into a nighttime venue for bands and DJs.
Overall, New York Pizza is a beloved local spot that combines quality food with a fun atmosphere.
Pros
• Authentic New York-style pizza
• Friendly and accommodating staff
• Cozy and casual atmosphere
• Live music on weekends
• Late-night service
• Wheelchair accessible
• Pet-friendly
• Offers delivery and takeout options
Cons
• Limited parking space
• Closed on Tuesdays
• Some reviews mention inconsistent service
• Occasional wait times during peak hours
Ideal for
• Casual dining with friends
• Late-night outings
• Enjoying live music
• Family gatherings
Things to know before visiting
• Offers takeout and delivery options
• Live music on weekends enhances the dining experience
• Closed on Tuesdays
Overall impression
New York Pizza is a beloved establishment in Greensboro, combining quality food with a lively atmosphere. With its authentic pizza and friendly service, it stands out as a top choice for both locals and visitors.
Nestled in the vibrant College Hill neighborhood of Greensboro, North Carolina, New York Pizza on Tate Street is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers and Italian food enthusiasts alike. This cozy pizzeria combines a laid-back bar atmosphere with authentic Italian flavors, making it perfect for casual dining, group gatherings, or catching live music. Whether you crave a classic slice or something more adventurous, New York Pizza delivers top-quality, made-to-order pies packed with fresh ingredients and traditional Italian flair.
New York Pizza goes beyond just traditional pizza. Their menu boasts delicious stromboli stuffed with a heavenly mix of cheese, meats, and a unique boudin blanc-style sausage that expertly balances rich Italian flavors without overpowering the crust or pepperoni. Fans rave about the veggie and buffalo chicken pizzas, chicken parm, arancini, and indulgent desserts like sweet cannoli drizzled with chocolate. Every dish is freshly made, giving you a taste experience that elevates casual Italian dining to something truly memorable.
Step into a warm, welcoming space where you can enjoy your meal while soaking up the lively bar vibe. The friendly crew serves up local beers like Red Oak on tap, daily drink specials, and well-crafted cocktails. The bar area, separate from the dining room, invites mingling and sometimes gets spirited with bar trivia nights and live music featuring bands and DJs. Whether you're here for a casual lunch, a fun night out, or to watch sports on their screens, New York Pizza’s inviting setting has something for everyone, including outdoor seating and free street parking.
- Delivery - Order your favorite dishes for delivery straight to your doorstep, perfect for busy days or cozy nights in.
- Takeout - Place an order ahead and pick up your food to enjoy the fresh flavors of New York Pizza at home or on the go.
- Dine-in - Enjoy your meal in a cozy, casual setting with friendly service, live music nights, and a vibrant community atmosphere.
Locals and visitors alike love New York Pizza not just for its exceptional, handcrafted pizzas and Italian specialties, but also for its welcoming vibe and commitment to quality. This spot is perfect for families, students from nearby UNCG, and anyone looking to enjoy a great meal with a comfortable atmosphere. The staff’s attention to detail—from handling a busy bar to providing generous dipping sauces—ensures every visit feels special. With gluten-friendly and vegetarian options available, plus the convenience of multiple payment methods including NFC, New York Pizza makes dining easy and enjoyable.
