Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

Stockholm, Sweden

Black Milk Gastro Bar

Gothenburg, Sweden

Brasserie Draken

Malmö, Sweden

Mutantur

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Kenya Safari

with Great Plains Conservation

in Maasai Mara

Guide to

Eat, Stay & Do

Rio de Janeiro

in Sweden

The Most Unique Spas

EAT & STAY

Summer in Europe

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

New Launch: August 2025

Zimbabwe

Mpala Jena Private Villas

for Your Next Long Haul Flight

Beauty Hacks

Luxury Travel on a Budget

How To:

for a Stress-Free Trip

Top 10 Travel Hacks

with 30% discount

Get Lounge Access

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Stockholm

Dog Friendly Dining

Explore

Koh Samui

A Tropical Getaway

Best Smoothie Bowls

Travel Guide

Koh Kood

Island Escape

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Columbus

Pizzeria New York in Reynoldsburg, OH, has garnered positive feedback for its authentic New York-style pizza, brick oven baking, and fresh ingredients. Customers appreciate the thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The menu offers a variety of specialty pizzas, oven-baked subs, and Italian entrees. While some reviews mention longer wait times, many find the quality of the food worth the wait. The casual atmosphere and friendly staff contribute to a welcoming dining experience.

Pizzeria New York in Reynoldsburg, OH, delivers an authentic taste of New York with its signature thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings baked in a traditional brick oven. This local favorite is known for huge, floppy slices and a menu featuring specialty pizzas, oven-baked subs, and classic Italian entrees. Perfect for pizza lovers seeking a genuine New York-style experience in Ohio.

Discover Pizzeria New York in Reynoldsburg Ohio's Pizza Gem 

From the first bite of their garlic knots to the last cheesy slice, customers frequently praise the freshness and quality of ingredients. The pizza’s delicate balance of a thin crust with generous toppings mirrors the classic New York style, making it a standout for pizza night. Family favorites and long-time regulars alike appreciate the quick order turnaround and friendly service that creates a welcoming community vibe.

While the restaurant specializes in takeout and delivery, it also offers a cozy dine-in option for those craving an on-site pizza feast. Free parking and multiple payment options, including credit cards and NFC, make your visit convenient and stress-free. Although outdoor seating and live music aren't available, the focus here remains on delivering quality pizza with a no-fuss, casual atmosphere.

Overall, Pizzeria New York enjoys positive sentiment from its community. Customers celebrate the authentic taste and generous portions, with many calling it the best pizza in Columbus area. Some occasional critiques mention tougher dough or wait times, but most agree that the warm, friendly staff and authentic flavors make it worth returning to.

FAQs about Pizzeria New York Reynoldsburg

What are the operating hours of Pizzeria New York in Reynoldsburg?

 Pizzeria New York operates Tuesday through Thursday from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.

Does Pizzeria New York offer delivery services?

 Yes, Pizzeria New York provides delivery services to customers in the Reynoldsburg area.

Is there a dine-in option at Pizzeria New York?

 Yes, Pizzeria New York offers dine-in services, allowing customers to enjoy their meals on-site.

Are there gluten-free options available at Pizzeria New York?

 While the menu does not explicitly mention gluten-free options, it's advisable to contact the restaurant directly to inquire about gluten-free choices.

Does Pizzeria New York accept credit cards?

 Yes, Pizzeria New York accepts major credit cards for payment.

North America

United States

Nestled in the heart of Reynoldsburg, Ohio, Pizzeria New York is a culinary gem that transports you straight to the bustling streets of New York City. With its vibrant atmosphere and the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air, this pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers. Whether you're a local or just passing through, the experience here is nothing short of delightful. The moment you step inside, you're greeted with a warm smile and the enticing sight of their signature pizzas being crafted right before your eyes.

At Pizzeria New York, the menu is a celebration of authentic Italian flavors, with a focus on fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. The star of the show is undoubtedly their Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza, a delightful combination of spicy pepperoni and a drizzle of sweet honey that creates a perfect balance of flavors. Each slice is generously topped with gooey mozzarella, making it a crowd favorite. For those looking for something unique, the Garlic Knots are a must-try. These fluffy, buttery bites are infused with garlic and herbs, served warm and perfect for dipping in marinara sauce.

One of the unique aspects of Pizzeria New York is their commitment to quality and authenticity. The dough is made fresh daily, ensuring that each pizza has that perfect crust—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. A fun fact: the owner, originally from New York, brings a piece of his hometown to Ohio, sharing his passion for pizza with the community. This dedication to craft is evident in every bite, making it a beloved spot for families and friends alike.

Pizzeria New York is renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza, particularly the Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza and delicious Garlic Knots.

This pizzeria offers a unique dining experience with its cozy atmosphere, delicious food, and friendly service, making it perfect for families and friends.

Pizzeria New York is conveniently located near various shopping centers and parks, making it an ideal stop after a day of exploring.

Whether you're craving a slice of the best pizza in Ohio or looking for a cozy spot to gather with friends, Pizzeria New York is the place to be. Come and indulge in their mouthwatering offerings, and experience the warmth of their hospitality. Don't miss out on the chance to savor a slice of New York right here in Reynoldsburg!

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNfeExyQjV3RRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJPWQHlDlkOIgRfQuI5BPj3q8/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNfeExyQjV3RRAB

The garlic knots were amazing and the pizza was very good! The order was ready very quickly too. A new family favorite for pizza night!

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURPNi1xTjdnRRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJPWQHlDlkOIgRfQuI5BPj3q8/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURPNi1xTjdnRRAB

Really good pizza!

We ordered pepperoni on all but two slices (for the kiddos) which they seemed to accommodate but then cut it wrong so the cheese slices ended up being half pepperoni half cheese anyway. But not a huge deal, I just re cut those slices when I got home. The pizza itself was really good. My husband and I both really liked the crust and taste. Huge slices and very Floppy - reminded me of Mikey's Late Night Slice. Good price.

We also ordered Garlic Knots which were really good as well! 🤌🏻

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURua2NIdFBBEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJPWQHlDlkOIgRfQuI5BPj3q8/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURua2NIdFBBEAE

Used to love this place but last night was far beyond disappointing. Sad to say I wasted nearly 40 bucks on food that was just flat out terrible.

Ordered an extra large pie, garlic knots and pepperoni rolls. Ordered pick up and I was right on time to receive the food "fresh". On all of those items mentioned the dough was extremely tough and frankly was just not edible.

Would love to think it was just a bad night or something because I usually love this place. Gonna be a while before I give them another chance.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUMtc3RHVnpBRRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJPWQHlDlkOIgRfQuI5BPj3q8/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUMtc3RHVnpBRRAB

BEST PIZZA IN OHIO !
Man I found out About this place while giving birth to my twins , I’m from New Jersey so it’s just a different kind of pizza I like ! The one cut into 8 slices 😂
The food was great prices was more than affordable!  My new weekly pizza place ‘ COME GRAB YOU A PIE OF PIZZA 🍕 THE CHEESE CAKE  WAS AMAZING ILL BE BACK !

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURQMjZUb0lREAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJPWQHlDlkOIgRfQuI5BPj3q8/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURQMjZUb0lREAE

Fantastic food and even better staff. Highly suggest the Hot honey Pepperoni pizza!!
11/10 Best pizza in Columbus!

Best Pizza in Reynoldsburg, OH - Pizzeria New York

Pizzeria New York is a family-owned establishment in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, known for its authentic New York-style pizza and Italian dishes. The restaurant utilizes a brick oven imported from Italy to bake its pizzas, ensuring a traditional taste. The menu features a variety of specialty pizzas, oven-baked subs, and Italian entrees, all made with fresh ingredients and homemade sauces.

Pizzeria New York: Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Reynoldsburg Ohio History Overview 

Nestled in the heart of Reynoldsburg, Ohio, Pizzeria New York brings a slice of authentic New York flavor to the Midwest. This family-owned gem has built a reputation for crafting traditional New York-style pizza, using a unique brick oven imported directly from Italy to deliver a genuine and irresistible taste. Their dedication to quality is evident in every specialty pizza, oven-baked sub, and Italian entree, all prepared with fresh ingredients and homemade sauces that evoke the spirit of Brooklyn and Queens.

Pizzeria New York was founded in 2003 in Pickerington, Ohio, with a clear mission: to authentically recreate the beloved flavors of New York's iconic pizza boroughs, Brooklyn and Queens. From the outset, the owners prioritized traditional techniques and attention to detail, setting themselves apart in a market eager for true New York-style pizza experiences. This dedication laid the foundation for their growing local fanbase.

Expansion to Reynoldsburg: 2019 and Beyond

In 2019, Pizzeria New York expanded its presence by opening a new location in Reynoldsburg, Ohio. This move broadened access to their authentic pies and Italian fare, attracting a wider audience who craved the classic New York pizza experience without traveling to the East Coast. The Reynoldsburg spot has since become a beloved neighborhood favorite, praised for its generous slices, flavorful crusts, and the unmistakable aroma of brick oven baking.

What makes Pizzeria New York special is not just the authentic recipes but the experience of savoring traditional New York-style pizza crafted with passion and expertise. The imported brick oven ensures each pizza is baked to perfection, producing a crisp yet chewy crust that holds up to hearty toppings. Their menu also includes oven-baked subs and classic Italian entrees, all crafted from scratch using high-quality, fresh ingredients and homemade sauces.

Established in 2003 in Pickerington to recreate Brooklyn and Queens flavors.

Opened Reynoldsburg location in 2019, expanding reach across Ohio.

Uses a traditional Italian brick oven for authentic baking.

Crafts menu items with fresh ingredients and homemade sauces.

Pizzeria New York’s history is a testament to the passion for authentic pizza and Italian cuisine. From its humble beginnings in Pickerington to its thriving presence in Reynoldsburg, it continues to delight pizza lovers with classic flavors crafted with care. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this restaurant offers a delicious slice of New York’s culinary heritage right in Ohio.

Authentic New York-style pizza and Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes.

Veggie Primavera

Eggplant Parm Pizza

Pap's Special

New York White

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Meat Special

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Barbecue Chicken Pizza

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

Greek Pizza

Chicken Bourbon Pizza

Cajun Bourbon Chicken Sub

BBQ Chicken Sub

Italian Sub

Eggplant Parmigiano

Meatball Parmigiano

Philly Cheese Steak

Grilled Chicken Sub

Spaghetti and Meatballs

Eggplant Parmigiano Entree

Pizzeria New York Menu

Discover the vibrant flavors of authentic New York-style pizza and classic Italian dishes at Pizzeria New York, located in the heart of Reynoldsburg, Ohio. This menu boasts a rich variety of freshly prepared options, crafted with traditional recipes and premium ingredients that cater to every craving.

Begin your meal with the highly praised garlic knots, a fan favorite praised for their perfect balance of softness and flavor. For a heartier start, try the Philly Cheese Steak sub or the Cajun Bourbon Chicken sub — both packed with savory meats, sautéed vegetables, and signature sauces that set the stage for an unforgettable dining experience.

The mains shine with a diverse range of pizza specialties and Italian classics that highlight fresh vegetables, premium cheeses, and seasoned meats. Vegetarian options include the Veggie Primavera, bursting with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and sliced tomatoes, and the Greek Pizza, featuring feta, red onions, sautéed spinach, and black olives. Eggplant lovers will delight in the Eggplant Parm Pizza and Eggplant Parmigiano Entree, each layered with mozzarella and homemade sauces.

For meat enthusiasts, the menu offers robust flavors like the Pap's Special with sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and banana peppers; the Meat Special loaded with sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and ham; and the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza topped with shaved steak, sautéed green peppers and onions, and American cheese. Chicken aficionados can indulge in the Chicken Alfredo Pizza with its creamy homemade Alfredo sauce, the spicy Buffalo Chicken Pizza served with a side of bleu cheese or ranch, the tangy Barbecue Chicken Pizza, and the unique Chicken Bourbon Pizza featuring bourbon sauce and bacon.

Submarine sandwiches round out the meal options with classic Italian and grilled chicken subs, each layered with flavorful cheeses, vegetables, and sauces like marinara, BBQ, or bourbon, offering a satisfying alternative to the pizza selections. Traditional Italian fare is represented by the Spaghetti and Meatballs, prepared with homemade marinara sauce and hand-rolled meatballs, delivering comfort with every bite.

End your meal on a sweet note with classic Italian desserts — while the menu specializes in savory delights, the cheesecake is notably a crowd favorite, celebrated for its creamy texture and rich flavor, making it the perfect finish to your Pizzeria New York experience.

Discover Pizzeria New York in Reynoldsburg, OH, offering delicious pizza for takeout or delivery. A must-visit for food lovers!

Pizzeria New York: Best Pizza in Reynoldsburg, OH

Franklin County

Pizzeria New York

Takeout

Enjoy our food delivered to your doorstep.

Delivery

Pizzeria New York in Reynoldsburg Ohio: Authentic New York Style Pizza To Go and Delivery!

Nestled in the heart of Reynoldsburg on East Broad Street, Pizzeria New York brings the quintessential New York pizza experience right to Ohio. Famous for its large, floppy slices and a crust that strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, this spot has quickly become a beloved favorite for pizza enthusiasts craving authentic flavor without leaving town.

Whether you're ordering for a family pizza night or a casual solo dinner, Pizzeria New York offers generous slices topped with your favorites like pepperoni, cheese, or their highly recommended Hot Honey Pepperoni—an exciting twist that has patrons raving. The garlic knots are another must-try, praised for their perfect seasoning and texture, making a tasty side that complements the pizza wonderfully.

Pizzeria New York specializes in takeout and delivery services, making it easy and convenient to enjoy their signature New York-style pizza wherever you are. Whether you're hosting a party or just craving a slice after a long day, their quick order preparation ensures your food arrives fresh and ready to devour. Plus, with free parking available, picking up your order is hassle-free.

 - Order your favorite dishes to go and enjoy classic New York flavors at home.

 - Enjoy their delicious pizza delivered straight to your doorstep, hot and fresh.

What customers love about Pizzeria New York

Visitors consistently praise the spot for its authentic New York style pizza, especially highlighting the crust's texture and the huge, floppy slices reminiscent of late-night favorite Mikey's. The garlic knots frequently receive glowing reviews for their flavor. Some loyal customers call it the best pizza in Ohio, appreciating the affordable prices and generous portions. While there have been rare reports of inconsistency, the overall buzz remains positive, making it a go-to place for a quick, delicious pizza fix in the Columbus area.

Ohio

Visit Pizzeria New York for delicious, authentic pizzas baked in a brick oven. Experience our family-friendly atmosphere and order for delivery or takeout!

Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Reynoldsburg | Pizzeria New York

Explore our mouth-watering menu at Pizzeria New York. From specialty pizzas to delicious subs, indulge in the best Italian in Reynoldsburg!

Ultimate Food Adventure: Pizzeria New York Menu

Discover the rich history of Pizzeria New York. From authentic recipes to quality ingredients, we bring the taste of New York to Reynoldsburg!

Best Pizza in Reynoldsburg, OH - Pizzeria New York

Dining & Culinary Delights

Signature Highlights

FAQs

Visit Us Today!