Pizzeria New York menu overview

Discover the vibrant flavors of authentic New York-style pizza and classic Italian dishes at Pizzeria New York, located in the heart of Reynoldsburg, Ohio. This menu boasts a rich variety of freshly prepared options, crafted with traditional recipes and premium ingredients that cater to every craving.

Starters and specials

Begin your meal with the highly praised garlic knots, a fan favorite praised for their perfect balance of softness and flavor. For a heartier start, try the Philly Cheese Steak sub or the Cajun Bourbon Chicken sub — both packed with savory meats, sautéed vegetables, and signature sauces that set the stage for an unforgettable dining experience.

Mains

The mains shine with a diverse range of pizza specialties and Italian classics that highlight fresh vegetables, premium cheeses, and seasoned meats. Vegetarian options include the Veggie Primavera, bursting with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and sliced tomatoes, and the Greek Pizza, featuring feta, red onions, sautéed spinach, and black olives. Eggplant lovers will delight in the Eggplant Parm Pizza and Eggplant Parmigiano Entree, each layered with mozzarella and homemade sauces.

For meat enthusiasts, the menu offers robust flavors like the Pap's Special with sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and banana peppers; the Meat Special loaded with sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and ham; and the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza topped with shaved steak, sautéed green peppers and onions, and American cheese. Chicken aficionados can indulge in the Chicken Alfredo Pizza with its creamy homemade Alfredo sauce, the spicy Buffalo Chicken Pizza served with a side of bleu cheese or ranch, the tangy Barbecue Chicken Pizza, and the unique Chicken Bourbon Pizza featuring bourbon sauce and bacon.

Submarine sandwiches round out the meal options with classic Italian and grilled chicken subs, each layered with flavorful cheeses, vegetables, and sauces like marinara, BBQ, or bourbon, offering a satisfying alternative to the pizza selections. Traditional Italian fare is represented by the Spaghetti and Meatballs, prepared with homemade marinara sauce and hand-rolled meatballs, delivering comfort with every bite.

Desserts

End your meal on a sweet note with classic Italian desserts — while the menu specializes in savory delights, the cheesecake is notably a crowd favorite, celebrated for its creamy texture and rich flavor, making it the perfect finish to your Pizzeria New York experience.

4.2

7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

(614) 868-3870

Closed - Opens 11:00 AM

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

15:00–21:00

Wednesday

15:00–21:00

Thursday

15:00–21:00