Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

Stockholm, Sweden

Black Milk Gastro Bar

Gothenburg, Sweden

Brasserie Draken

Malmö, Sweden

Mutantur

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Kenya Safari

with Great Plains Conservation

in Maasai Mara

Guide to

Eat, Stay & Do

Rio de Janeiro

in Sweden

The Most Unique Spas

EAT & STAY

Summer in Europe

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

New Launch: August 2025

Zimbabwe

Mpala Jena Private Villas

for Your Next Long Haul Flight

Beauty Hacks

Luxury Travel on a Budget

How To:

for a Stress-Free Trip

Top 10 Travel Hacks

with 30% discount

Get Lounge Access

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Stockholm

Dog Friendly Dining

Explore

Koh Samui

A Tropical Getaway

Best Smoothie Bowls

Travel Guide

Koh Kood

Island Escape

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Broken Arrow

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, is celebrated for its authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza, fresh ingredients, and friendly service. Customers frequently commend the family-owned atmosphere and the quality of the food, highlighting favorites like the Bronx Chicken Alfredo and Manhattan Meat pizzas. The restaurant's clean environment and accommodating staff further enhance the dining experience.

Experience authentic New York-style pizza at Jimmy's New York Pizzeria in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, where every slice tells a story of tradition and flavor.

Nestled in the heart of Broken Arrow at 3312 South Elm Place, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria has quickly become a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking the quintessential taste of New York thin-crust pizza. This family-owned gem offers a welcoming atmosphere where you can indulge in generous, perfectly cooked slices that bring the Big Apple straight to Oklahoma.

Jimmy's is more than just pizza; it's a community favorite known for its authentic recipes and heartfelt service. Diners rave about the Bronx Chicken Alfredo and the Manhattan Meat pizzas, praising the fresh, high-quality ingredients and the perfectly thin, crispy crust. The spacious and clean dining area with abundant natural light creates a comfortable setting for friends and families alike.

From the iconic Staten Island White to the cheese garlic knots, Jimmy’s offers a variety of dishes that satisfy both classic and adventurous palates. Their generous pizza slices are consistently cooked to perfection, delighting guests on every visit. Don’t miss out on the cheesecake calzone, a uniquely indulgent dessert that keeps customers coming back for more.

 calls it one of his favorite pizza joints with huge, perfectly cooked slices and great service. Meanwhile, John Williams highlights the friendly staff and gigantic slices, recommending everyone to check out this vibrant spot. C. Stafford shares a memorable experience where the team went above and beyond to ensure quality, showing how much Jimmy's values its customers.

What are the operating hours of Jimmy's New York Pizzeria?

 The restaurant operates Tuesday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM. It is closed on Mondays.

Does Jimmy's New York Pizzeria offer delivery services?

 Yes, they offer delivery services, allowing customers to enjoy their meals at home.

Is there parking available at Jimmy's New York Pizzeria?

 Yes, the restaurant provides ample parking for its patrons.

 Reservations are not required but can be made for parties or special events.

Does the restaurant offer gluten-free options?

 Yes, they offer gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

 is the prevailing mood among locals and visitors alike. Praise consistently focuses on the authenticity of the New York-style thin-crust pizza, the friendly and attentive service, and the inviting family-owned atmosphere that makes every visit special.

Whether you're craving a classic New York cheese slice or adventurous flavors like Bronx Chicken Alfredo, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria delivers an authentic experience with a local twist—making it a standout spot for food lovers visiting or living in Broken Arrow.

North America

United States

Nestled in the heart of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is a vibrant eatery that brings a taste of the Big Apple to the Midwest. With its spacious layout and welcoming atmosphere, this pizzeria is perfect for families, friends, and anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza. The moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked dough and rich tomato sauce envelops you, promising a delightful culinary experience.

At Jimmy's, the standout dishes are the Staten Island White and the Bronx Chicken Alfredo. The Staten Island White is a masterpiece, featuring a perfectly baked thin crust topped with garlic oil, fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, and a generous dollop of ricotta cheese, creating a creamy, savory delight that dances on your palate. Meanwhile, the Bronx Chicken Alfredo showcases tender chicken pieces smothered in a rich, creamy Alfredo sauce, served atop a bed of perfectly cooked pasta, making it a comforting choice for any pasta lover.

The restaurant prides itself on quality and service. A memorable anecdote from a recent visitor highlights this commitment: after a small mistake in their order, the staff promptly made a new pizza without hesitation, allowing the guests to enjoy the "ugly" pizza while they waited. This level of care and attention to detail is what keeps customers coming back for more.

Located at 3312 S Elm Pl, Broken Arrow, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is conveniently situated for both locals and travelers. Just a short drive away, you can explore the scenic parks and vibrant shopping districts of Broken Arrow. Whether you're visiting the nearby Rose District or enjoying a day at the local parks, Jimmy's is the perfect stop for a delicious meal after a day of exploration.

What is Jimmy's New York Pizzeria known for?

Jimmy's is renowned for its gigantic New York-style pizza slices and a diverse menu that includes pasta, calzones, and desserts.

If you're looking for authentic New York pizza in a friendly atmosphere, Jimmy's is a must-visit. The quality of food and service is exceptional.

You can explore the Rose District, local parks, and shopping areas, making it a great spot to refuel after a day of activities.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Jimmy's New York Pizzeria for a slice (or two) of their famous pizza. With a menu that caters to all tastes and a commitment to quality, this pizzeria is ready to welcome you with open arms. Don't miss out on the chance to indulge in a delicious meal that will leave you craving more.

This busy spot with ample seating offers thin-crust pizzas & other typical fare in a low-key space.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmNk1YMEhnEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJyX_4p76NtocR1eKGBgyuaIk/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmNk1YMEhnEAE

I got the Staten Island White, Bronx Chicken Alfredo, cheese garlic knots. Slices were huge and cooked perfectly. Probably one of my new favorite pizza joints. The knots aren't bad, but I could live without them. Service was great, check it out yourself.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURua2UtOVF3EAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJyX_4p76NtocR1eKGBgyuaIk/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURua2UtOVF3EAE

Just left this place, and it was great. The staff was awesome, met the owner and he’s very high energy like me, was a funny guy. The pizza slices are absolutely gigantic and cooked well. Recommend coming here

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNMb0xiaVR3EAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJyX_4p76NtocR1eKGBgyuaIk/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNMb0xiaVR3EAE

Whether or not it is “New York” style or not is irrelevant to me. I ain’t much of a pizza critic. A Pizza Hut sausage on thin crust with a cold beer, works for me!
But today, my wife and I were looking for a white pizza. That search brought us to the new Broken Arrow, Jimmy’s New York Pizza for a pan of Staten Island White. It was and excellent example of crust covered with Garlic Oil Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Sliced Tomatoes, Fresh Ricotta Cheese & Minced Garlic. It was enjoyable, but not quite what I was looking for in a white pizza.  I think Bronx Chicken Alfredo will be closer to matching the memory I have of one I enjoyed many years ago.

The restaurant is spacious. Windows all around. Clean with good friendly service.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNMbktxVHJRRRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJyX_4p76NtocR1eKGBgyuaIk/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNMbktxVHJRRRAB

The better half told me she wanted New York style pizza, you know BIG slices, so we tried Jimmy's. The staff was friendly, the restaurant was clean, and the pizza was delicious.

Furthermore, a small mistake happened during the making of our pizza. Where most places would have just served you a subpar pizza, they did not. Without even asking us, they made another pizza. Gave us the "ugly" pizza to eat while we waited.

This alone proves quality is important at Jimmy's. We will definitely order again. I recommend you do the same.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUM1X3NHYkdnEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJyX_4p76NtocR1eKGBgyuaIk/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUM1X3NHYkdnEAE

We wanted to try it for quite a few weeks and ended up going 2 days in a row. Great customer service, amazing prices, and great pizza. Crispy and pipping hot crust, 🔥 made these pizzas amazing. We had the Manhattan Meat & the New York cheese, a slice of the State Island White, a classic cannoli, 2 Ghiradelli chocolate cheese cake,  plain and a cherry New York cheese cakes on our 1st visit. The next day, we had a New York cheese and a Bronx Chicken Alfredo to go. Both times, the service was on point, the quality and flavor were amazing, and the prices were extremely reasonable. We are definitely returning to try more menu items, especially the Cheesecake Calzone 😋

Best New York Pizza in Broken Arrow, OK - Jimmy's Pizzeria

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is a family-owned establishment in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, known for its authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza and Italian dishes. The restaurant has garnered a loyal following for its fresh ingredients, friendly service, and commitment to quality.

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria History Overview in Broken Arrow Oklahoma 

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is a beloved family-owned restaurant located at 3312 South Elm Place in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. Since opening its doors in 2017, this establishment has become synonymous with authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza and classic Italian dishes, attracting a loyal local following. Known for its commitment to quality, fresh ingredients, and friendly service, Jimmy's has steadily grown into a community staple for pizza lovers and families alike.

Established in 2017, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria brought a true taste of New York to the Tulsa County area. From the beginning, the focus was on delivering large, perfectly cooked slices of traditional thin-crust pizza that captured the essence of New York’s iconic style. This emphasis on authenticity and quality quickly set the pizzeria apart in Broken Arrow’s dining scene.

In 2019, responding to growing demand and diverse tastes, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria expanded its menu to include a variety of pasta dishes and desserts. This broadening of offerings provided customers with more choices beyond pizza, enhancing the dining experience and appealing to a wider audience. The addition of classic Italian dishes and tempting desserts strengthened Jimmy's reputation as a full-service Italian eatery committed to quality and flavor.

By 2021, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria celebrated its 4th anniversary, a significant milestone highlighting its sustained success and dedication to customer satisfaction. Over the years, the pizzeria’s commitment to serving fresh ingredients and providing friendly service has earned it rave reviews and a loyal customer base. Patrons appreciate the generous pizza slices, authentic flavors, and the welcoming atmosphere that makes Jimmy's a top choice in Broken Arrow for pizza and Italian cuisine.

 Jimmy's New York Pizzeria opened its doors in Broken Arrow, bringing authentic New York-style pizza to the community.

 The menu was expanded to include pasta dishes and desserts, offering more variety to patrons.

 The pizzeria marked its 4th anniversary, celebrating years of quality and customer devotion.

Authentic New York-style pizza, pasta, and desserts made fresh to order.

Liberty Supreme Pizza

Manhattan Meat Slice

Bronx Chicken Alfredo

Staten Island White

Garlic Cheese Bread

Garlic Knots

New York Cheesecake Slice

Cheesecake Calzone

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Menu

Jimmy's New York pizzeria menu overview in broken arrow oklahoma usa.

Discover the authentic flavors of New York right in Broken Arrow at Jimmy's New York Pizzeria, where generous slices and classic recipes come to life. This vibrant pizzeria offers a distinctive assortment of dishes, perfect for pizza lovers and fans of hearty Italian-American cuisine. Dive into their menu crafted to satisfy hearty appetites and provide a genuine taste of New York-style pizza, pasta, and desserts made fresh to order.

Kick off your meal with delicious starters that set the tone for an authentic New York pizzeria experience. The Garlic Cheese Bread is a savory delight, loaded with garlic butter, melted mozzarella, parmesan cheese, and a sprinkle of Italian herbs on freshly baked bread. Complementing this is the popular Garlic Knots, soft knots of pizza dough brushed with garlic butter, parmesan, and herbs for a flavorful bite.

The star of the menu is undoubtedly the array of New York-style pizzas, each boasting a thin, crispy crust and generous toppings. The Liberty Supreme Pizza is a loaded masterpiece with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, olives, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and marinara sauce, delivering rich complexity in every bite. For meat lovers, the Manhattan Meat Slice offers a robust combination of pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham atop a mozzarella and marinara base.

Pasta enthusiasts will relish the Bronx Chicken Alfredo, featuring grilled chicken, creamy alfredo sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, garlic, parsley, and fettuccine pasta — a comforting dish with a flavorful punch. For a unique white pizza experience, the Staten Island White combines garlic oil sauce, fresh mozzarella, ricotta cheese, sliced tomatoes, minced garlic, and parmesan for a delicately balanced and aromatic meal option.

No meal is complete without a sweet finish, and Jimmy’s offers classic New York desserts that melt in your mouth. Indulge in a slice of creamy New York Cheesecake, crafted with cream cheese, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, and a graham cracker crust. For something more adventurous, try the Cheesecake Calzone, which wraps the cheesecake filling along with a touch of marinara sauce inside a golden crust—a delightful blend of savory and sweet.

While the menu focuses on hearty meals and desserts, the pizzeria also serves beer to complement your dining experience, enhancing the flavors of their classic pizzas and pastas. Whether you’re dining in or ordering takeout, Jimmy’s New York Pizzeria in Broken Arrow ensures quality, generous portions, and friendly service.

Authentic New York-style thin crust pizzas

 featuring everything from the Liberty Supreme to the Staten Island White.

 like the Bronx Chicken Alfredo crafted with grilled chicken and rich cheeses.

 like Garlic Cheese Bread and Garlic Knots to share or enjoy solo.

 including New York Cheesecake slices and the inventive Cheesecake Calzone.

 to perfectly pair with your favorite slice or pasta dish.

Discover Jimmy's New York Pizzeria in Broken Arrow, OK, for delicious pizza and meal delivery options sure to delight every palate!

Delicious Pizza at Jimmy's in Broken Arrow, OK

Tulsa County

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow

Order ahead and have your meal brought to your car upon arrival.

Curbside Pickup

Enjoy our delicious food delivered straight to your doorstep.

Delivery

Order your favorite dishes to-go for a convenient meal at home.

Takeout

Experience our cozy atmosphere while enjoying your meal.

Dine-in

Reserve a space for your next event or gathering.

Party Reservations

Let us cater your next event with our delicious menu options.

Catering

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Authentic Big Slices and More in Oklahoma's Heartland.

Nestled in the vibrant city of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria offers a truly authentic slice of New York's iconic pizza culture. Located at 3312 South Elm Place, this bustling spot is a must-visit for pizza lovers craving gigantic, perfectly cooked thin-crust slices that pack a punch in flavor and size.

At Jimmy's, every pizza is crafted to bring the authentic New York experience to Oklahoma. Favorites like the Staten Island White with its rich garlic oil sauce, fresh mozzarella, and ricotta, and the Bronx Chicken Alfredo offer unique flavor profiles that keep locals coming back. Don't miss their cheese garlic knots – a cheesy delight though some might find them optional!

 are a hallmark here, with slices described as "absolutely gigantic" and cooked to perfection, ensuring you'll leave satisfied every time.

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is designed for all kinds of diners. Whether you're craving a sit-down meal in a spacious, clean environment with friendly service or need a quick bite on the go, Jimmy's has you covered. The restaurant offers dine-in seating with a cozy, low-key atmosphere and large windows letting in plenty of natural light.

 - Enjoy a cozy meal on-site with attentive and friendly staff.

 - Order ahead and have your meal waiting for you, even delivered to your car.

 - Have your favorite pizzas and desserts brought right to your doorstep free of delivery charge.

 - Reserve space or let Jimmy’s cater your next event with delicious options everyone will love.

Patrons rave about the gigantic slice sizes and the friendly, high-energy staff. Many call Jimmy’s their favorite pizzeria in Broken Arrow, praising their consistency, crispy thin crust, and flavorful toppings. The staff's commitment to quality is evident, as they don’t hesitate to remake a pizza to ensure customer satisfaction. Plus, the prices remain reasonable, making it a perfect spot for families, groups, and pizza aficionados alike.

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria also serves delicious desserts like classic cannoli and rich Ghirardelli chocolate cheesecakes, including unique items like the Cheesecake Calzone. They serve beer to complement your meal, making it a well-rounded dining destination for lunch and dinner alike. The restaurant welcomes families, including children, with menu options that cater to younger tastes.

 include free parking lots and street parking, as well as accepting NFC, credit, and debit cards for hassle-free transactions.

Why choose Jimmy's New York Pizzeria in Broken Arrow

 including dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery.

 with menu options suitable for children.

Oklahoma

Enjoy Brooklyn-style pizza, pasta & desserts at Jimmy's in Broken Arrow, OK. Family-friendly, fresh ingredients & quick delivery. Visit us today!

Jimmy's New York Pizza Broken Arrow - Authentic NYC Flavor

Savor authentic New York-style pizza, pasta, and desserts in Broken Arrow, OK. Friendly service, outdoor seating, and convenient takeout options available.

Jimmy's New York Pizza, Broken Arrow - Delicious & Cozy

Experience the taste of NYC with Jimmy's signature pizzas, garlic knots & cheesecakes. Located in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. Reserve your table now!

Best New York Pizza in Broken Arrow, OK - Jimmy's Pizzeria

Dining & Culinary Delights

Location & Nearby Attractions

FAQs

Visit Us Today