Nestled in the heart of Broken Arrow at 3312 South Elm Place, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria has quickly become a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking the quintessential taste of New York thin-crust pizza. This family-owned gem offers a welcoming atmosphere where you can indulge in generous, perfectly cooked slices that bring the Big Apple straight to Oklahoma.
Jimmy's is more than just pizza; it's a community favorite known for its authentic recipes and heartfelt service. Diners rave about the Bronx Chicken Alfredo and the Manhattan Meat pizzas, praising the fresh, high-quality ingredients and the perfectly thin, crispy crust. The spacious and clean dining area with abundant natural light creates a comfortable setting for friends and families alike.
From the iconic Staten Island White to the cheese garlic knots, Jimmy’s offers a variety of dishes that satisfy both classic and adventurous palates. Their generous pizza slices are consistently cooked to perfection, delighting guests on every visit. Don’t miss out on the cheesecake calzone, a uniquely indulgent dessert that keeps customers coming back for more.
Zakary Sisk calls it one of his favorite pizza joints with huge, perfectly cooked slices and great service. Meanwhile, John Williams highlights the friendly staff and gigantic slices, recommending everyone to check out this vibrant spot. C. Stafford shares a memorable experience where the team went above and beyond to ensure quality, showing how much Jimmy's values its customers.
- What are the operating hours of Jimmy's New York Pizzeria? The restaurant operates Tuesday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM. It is closed on Mondays.
- Does Jimmy's New York Pizzeria offer delivery services? Yes, they offer delivery services, allowing customers to enjoy their meals at home.
- Is there parking available at Jimmy's New York Pizzeria? Yes, the restaurant provides ample parking for its patrons.
- Are reservations required for dining in? Reservations are not required but can be made for parties or special events.
- Does the restaurant offer gluten-free options? Yes, they offer gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.
Positive is the prevailing mood among locals and visitors alike. Praise consistently focuses on the authenticity of the New York-style thin-crust pizza, the friendly and attentive service, and the inviting family-owned atmosphere that makes every visit special.
Whether you're craving a classic New York cheese slice or adventurous flavors like Bronx Chicken Alfredo, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria delivers an authentic experience with a local twist—making it a standout spot for food lovers visiting or living in Broken Arrow.
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is a beloved family-owned restaurant located at 3312 South Elm Place in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. Since opening its doors in 2017, this establishment has become synonymous with authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza and classic Italian dishes, attracting a loyal local following. Known for its commitment to quality, fresh ingredients, and friendly service, Jimmy's has steadily grown into a community staple for pizza lovers and families alike.
Established in 2017, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria brought a true taste of New York to the Tulsa County area. From the beginning, the focus was on delivering large, perfectly cooked slices of traditional thin-crust pizza that captured the essence of New York’s iconic style. This emphasis on authenticity and quality quickly set the pizzeria apart in Broken Arrow’s dining scene.
In 2019, responding to growing demand and diverse tastes, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria expanded its menu to include a variety of pasta dishes and desserts. This broadening of offerings provided customers with more choices beyond pizza, enhancing the dining experience and appealing to a wider audience. The addition of classic Italian dishes and tempting desserts strengthened Jimmy's reputation as a full-service Italian eatery committed to quality and flavor.
By 2021, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria celebrated its 4th anniversary, a significant milestone highlighting its sustained success and dedication to customer satisfaction. Over the years, the pizzeria’s commitment to serving fresh ingredients and providing friendly service has earned it rave reviews and a loyal customer base. Patrons appreciate the generous pizza slices, authentic flavors, and the welcoming atmosphere that makes Jimmy's a top choice in Broken Arrow for pizza and Italian cuisine.
- 2017: Jimmy's New York Pizzeria opened its doors in Broken Arrow, bringing authentic New York-style pizza to the community.
- 2019: The menu was expanded to include pasta dishes and desserts, offering more variety to patrons.
- 2021: The pizzeria marked its 4th anniversary, celebrating years of quality and customer devotion.
Located at 3312 S Elm Pl, Broken Arrow, OK, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza in a welcoming atmosphere. This family-owned establishment has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, known for its thin-crust pizzas and friendly service. With ample seating and a menu that caters to various tastes, it’s an ideal spot for casual dining or takeout.
- Authentic New York-style thin-crust pizza
- Fresh ingredients
- Friendly and accommodating staff
- Family-owned atmosphere
- Variety of menu options including gluten-free
- Delivery and takeout services available
- Limited operating hours (closed on Mondays)
- Some reviews mention occasional cleanliness issues
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is perfect for families, casual dining with friends, or anyone craving a slice of authentic pizza. With its spacious seating and friendly staff, it’s also suitable for group gatherings or celebrations.
- Check hours of operation as they are closed on Mondays.
- Parking is available with both free street and lot options.
- Reservations are recommended for larger groups.
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow stands out for its authentic pizza and welcoming environment. While there are minor drawbacks, such as limited hours and occasional cleanliness concerns, the overall experience is positive. With its delicious offerings and friendly service, it’s a must-try for pizza lovers in Broken Arrow.
Nestled in the vibrant city of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, Jimmy's New York Pizzeria offers a truly authentic slice of New York's iconic pizza culture. Located at 3312 South Elm Place, this bustling spot is a must-visit for pizza lovers craving gigantic, perfectly cooked thin-crust slices that pack a punch in flavor and size.
At Jimmy's, every pizza is crafted to bring the authentic New York experience to Oklahoma. Favorites like the Staten Island White with its rich garlic oil sauce, fresh mozzarella, and ricotta, and the Bronx Chicken Alfredo offer unique flavor profiles that keep locals coming back. Don't miss their cheese garlic knots – a cheesy delight though some might find them optional!
Generous portion sizes are a hallmark here, with slices described as "absolutely gigantic" and cooked to perfection, ensuring you'll leave satisfied every time.
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria is designed for all kinds of diners. Whether you're craving a sit-down meal in a spacious, clean environment with friendly service or need a quick bite on the go, Jimmy's has you covered. The restaurant offers dine-in seating with a cozy, low-key atmosphere and large windows letting in plenty of natural light.
- Dine-in - Enjoy a cozy meal on-site with attentive and friendly staff.
- Takeout & Curbside Pickup - Order ahead and have your meal waiting for you, even delivered to your car.
- Delivery - Have your favorite pizzas and desserts brought right to your doorstep free of delivery charge.
- Party Reservations and Catering - Reserve space or let Jimmy’s cater your next event with delicious options everyone will love.
Patrons rave about the gigantic slice sizes and the friendly, high-energy staff. Many call Jimmy’s their favorite pizzeria in Broken Arrow, praising their consistency, crispy thin crust, and flavorful toppings. The staff's commitment to quality is evident, as they don’t hesitate to remake a pizza to ensure customer satisfaction. Plus, the prices remain reasonable, making it a perfect spot for families, groups, and pizza aficionados alike.
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria also serves delicious desserts like classic cannoli and rich Ghirardelli chocolate cheesecakes, including unique items like the Cheesecake Calzone. They serve beer to complement your meal, making it a well-rounded dining destination for lunch and dinner alike. The restaurant welcomes families, including children, with menu options that cater to younger tastes.
Parking and payment options include free parking lots and street parking, as well as accepting NFC, credit, and debit cards for hassle-free transactions.
- Authentic New York-style pizza with generous, satisfying slices.
- Multiple convenient dining options including dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with menu options suitable for children.
- Reasonable prices and high quality that keep customers loyal and happy.
