Big Mario's Pizza: Seattle's New York Slice Haven with a Retro Twist

Name: Big Mario's Pizza
Address: 1009 E Pike St, Seattle, WA 98122, USA, Seattle, 98122, US
Telephone: (206) 922-3875
Price range: $$

Nestled in the heart of Capitol Hill at 1009 East Pike Street, Big Mario's Pizza serves up generous, authentic New York-style pizza slices that have earned a devoted following in Seattle. This vibrant spot pairs its signature street pizzas with a lively dive-bar atmosphere, making it a top choice for locals and visitors craving a bold, flavorful slice alongside refreshing cocktails and beers.

A standout destination for pizza lovers and night owls alike

Whether you're stopping by for a casual bite during lunch, unwinding with late-night slices, or grabbing takeout to enjoy at home, Big Mario's offers a menu with something for every palate. Their large 18-inch pizzas are especially praised for satisfying hunger with a crispy yet soft crust, though some visitors note that these slices are best enjoyed fresh due to their delicate texture. The kitchen caters to diverse dietary preferences, featuring vegan-friendly pizzas topped with plant-based cheese and vibrant veggies, ensuring no one misses out on the feast. The establishment also welcomes furry friends, creating a welcoming vibe for pet owners.

Menu and atmosphere highlights

Big Mario's blends the charm of a retro dive bar with the energy of a bustling New York pizzeria. Inside, you'll find an upbeat ambiance accentuated by hardcore EDM beats and a friendly staff ready to make your visit memorable. Aside from pizza, the bar serves a curated selection of beers, wines, and creative cocktails to perfectly complement your meal.

Dine-in experience Enjoy your pizza fresh from the oven in a laid-back, dive-bar setting that’s perfect for groups or solo visits.
Takeout and delivery Convenient options for enjoying Big Mario’s legendary pizza at home or on the go.
Vegan and vegetarian options Delicious plant-based pizzas that satisfy meat-free cravings.
Bar offerings Beer, wine, and cocktails served in a retro, inviting ambiance.

Community sentiment and reviews

Big Mario's Pizza enjoys a generally positive reputation within Seattle's food scene. Fans appreciate the restaurant’s authentic NYC-style slices, generous portions, and the electric dive-bar vibe that makes each visit feel like a special occasion. Many diners highlight the friendly, welcoming staff and the quality of the pizza, though opinions on some menu items like sauce and crust texture vary.

However, some reviews have pointed out occasional service inconsistencies and moments where customer interactions fell short of expectations. Despite these challenges, Big Mario’s remains a beloved late-night spot for pizza enthusiasts and those seeking a fun, casual dining experience in Capitol Hill.

Frequently asked questions about Big Mario's Pizza

What are the operating hours of Big Mario's Pizza? Big Mario's Pizza operates from 12:00 PM to 1:00 AM on Sundays through Thursdays, and from 12:00 PM to 2:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Is there a bar at Big Mario's Pizza? Yes, Big Mario's Pizza features a full bar offering a selection of beers, wines, and cocktails in a retro, dive-bar atmosphere.
Does Big Mario's Pizza offer vegan options? Yes, Big Mario's Pizza provides vegan-friendly options, including a vegan pizza with plant-based cheese and a variety of vegetables.
Is Big Mario's Pizza pet-friendly? Yes, Big Mario's Pizza is pet-friendly, allowing patrons to bring their pets while enjoying their meal.
Does Big Mario's Pizza offer delivery or takeout services? Yes, Big Mario's Pizza offers both delivery and takeout services, catering to customers who prefer to enjoy their meals at home.

History of Big Mario's Pizza in Seattle's Capitol Hill and Beyond.

Founded in 2010, Big Mario's Pizza quickly carved out a reputation for delivering authentic New York-style pizza right in the heart of Seattle's vibrant Capitol Hill neighborhood. This beloved pizzeria became known not only for its generous slices but also for the inviting and retro dive-bar vibe that fills its spaces, making it a hotspot for locals and visitors alike who crave quality pizza in a casual atmosphere.

Expansion and growth milestones

Big Mario's began as a single location on East Pike Street in Capitol Hill but soon expanded its presence to capture a broader Seattle audience. In 2015, the pizzeria opened its Queen Anne location, extending its reach and solidifying its status as a go-to pizza destination. Two years later, in 2017, plans were announced to introduce a location in the Frelard area, signaling continued growth and popularity.

The most recent milestone came in 2022 with the launch of the White Center location, which enhanced the Big Mario's experience by adding a cozy game room and a full bar. This addition transformed the venue into more than just a pizzeria; it became a lively social hub, appealing to diverse groups looking for great pizza paired with a fun and relaxed environment.

Big Mario's today: a blend of tradition and vibrant culture

Big Mario's Pizza continues to be a cornerstone of Seattle's food scene by offering its signature New York-style slices with a distinct local flair. Whether you're grabbing a slice on Capitol Hill, enjoying a drink at White Center, or planning a visit to one of their other locations, Big Mario's delivers an energetic and inclusive vibe that welcomes pizza lovers, foodies, and casual diners alike.

Key highlights and visitor experiences

Authentic New York-style pizza served in generous slices that capture the spirit of NYC street food.
Multiple Seattle locations including Capitol Hill, Queen Anne, and White Center to serve a wide range of neighborhoods.
Vibrant atmosphere with retro dive-bar vibes, EDM music, and friendly staff that elevate the dining experience.
Family-friendly and group-oriented settings with options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery to suit all occasions.

Big Mario's Pizza at a glance

Located at 1009 E Pike St in Seattle's vibrant Capitol Hill neighborhood, Big Mario's Pizza serves generous NYC-style pizza slices, cocktails, and beer in a laid-back space with a retro dive-bar vibe. This establishment is known for its late-night service and friendly atmosphere, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike.

With a focus on authentic New York-style pizza, Big Mario's offers a cozy environment perfect for grabbing a slice or enjoying a night out with friends.

Pros

• Authentic New York-style pizza • Generous slice sizes • Friendly and attentive staff • Full bar with cocktails, beer, and wine • Late-night service • Cozy atmosphere with a retro dive-bar vibe • Vegan-friendly options • Wheelchair accessible • Family-friendly environment • Offers delivery and takeout services

Cons

• Limited seating capacity • Can be crowded during peak hours • No gluten-free crust options available • No outdoor seating • No live music

Ideal for

Big Mario's Pizza is perfect for casual dining, late-night cravings, and gatherings with friends. It's a great spot for pizza lovers looking for a slice of New York in Seattle.

Things to know before visiting

Consider calling ahead for takeout orders, especially during peak hours. Parking options include both free and paid street parking nearby. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible but does not offer outdoor seating.

Overall impression

Big Mario's Pizza offers a delightful experience for pizza enthusiasts in Seattle. While it may have some limitations, such as seating capacity and price, the quality of the pizza and the friendly atmosphere make it a worthwhile visit. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a night out, Big Mario's is a solid choice for authentic New York-style pizza.

4.3

Oliver

Jarrett