Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, Blue Marble Ice Cream was more than just an ice cream parlor; it was a beloved community gem that drew locals and visitors alike with its commitment to organic, small-batch delights. Known for using locally sourced ingredients, this upscale spot offered a unique twist on frozen treats that delighted the taste buds and warmed the heart.
Blue Marble Ice Cream stood out for its innovative and classic flavors, including fan favorites like Vanilla, Butter Pecan, and Banana Chip, as well as distinctive creations such as Rose and Bread or the flagship Blue Marble—a delightful blend of blue vanilla with peanut butter and marshmallow. Customers could sample flavors before choosing their perfect scoop, accommodating both dairy lovers and vegans with a selection of four vegan options.
The friendly staff and inviting decor in shades of baby blue and white created an atmosphere that was both hip and welcoming, perfect for enjoying a cone under the apple trees in the charming outdoor seating area.
Beyond ice cream, Blue Marble offered a curated menu of coffee, including nitro cold brew and maple lattes, alongside fresh baked goods and light lunch options. This made it an ideal spot for a leisurely morning breakfast or an afternoon pick-me-up. The establishment embraced modern payment methods, accepting credit, debit, and NFC payments, enhancing convenience for all visitors.
The lively outdoor seating area often featured live music, creating a vibrant community vibe where patrons could relax, enjoy their treats, and soak in the Brooklyn atmosphere.
For 15 years, Blue Marble Ice Cream was a cherished part of Brooklyn’s food scene. The community sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive, fondly remembering the shop's warm service, organic ingredients, and innovative flavors. While the shop permanently closed its doors on December 24, 2023, its legacy as a pioneer of quality, sustainable ice cream continues to inspire.
- Is Blue Marble Ice Cream still open? No, Blue Marble Ice Cream closed its last remaining shop in Brooklyn on December 24, 2023.
- What were some popular flavors at Blue Marble Ice Cream? Popular flavors included Vanilla, Butter Pecan, Banana Chip, Coconut Chocolate Almond, Mint Chip, and unique options like Rose and Bread.
- Did Blue Marble Ice Cream offer vegan options? Yes, Blue Marble Ice Cream offered vegan options among their flavors.
Founded in 2008, Blue Marble Ice Cream swiftly established itself as a pioneering force in Brooklyn's artisanal food scene. From its original location on Atlantic Avenue, this ice cream shop championed organic, small-batch creations crafted with the freshest locally sourced ingredients, inspiring a devoted following among food lovers seeking quality and sustainability.
By 2014, Blue Marble Ice Cream had grown with the opening of its Prospect Heights location on Underhill Avenue, a vibrant neighborhood hub characterized by its welcoming outdoor seating and community atmosphere. The shop became a local favorite, known for inventive flavors like blue vanilla with peanut butter and marshmallow, alongside classic organic options. Its commitment to quality and innovation earned it a special place in Brooklyn's culinary landscape.
- 2008 - Blue Marble Ice Cream opened its first location on Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn.
- 2014 - The Underhill Avenue location opened in Prospect Heights, becoming a neighborhood favorite.
- 2017 - The Underhill Avenue shop underwent renovations to enhance its inviting rustic charm.
- 2023 - The Underhill Avenue location closed permanently on December 24, concluding 15 years of delicious service.
Throughout its 15 years, Blue Marble Ice Cream not only delighted Brooklyn residents but also extended its mission globally, opening additional locations in Manhattan and internationally in Rwanda and Haiti, promoting organic and sustainable ice cream production. Its influence resonated well beyond its charming Underhill Avenue venue, which remains fondly remembered for its friendly staff, unique flavors, and inviting atmosphere under apple trees and warm outdoor lights.
Blue Marble Ice Cream's lasting legacy lies in its dedication to organic ingredients, community engagement, and creative flavor profiles that elevated the ice cream experience in Brooklyn and beyond. Even though the physical locations have closed, the brand's influence continues to inspire chefs, food artisans, and environmentally conscious consumers who value quality, sustainability, and authentic flavors.
- Organic and locally sourced ingredients formed the heart of Blue Marble's offerings.
- Innovative flavors like the flagship Blue Marble and Rose and Bread set it apart from traditional ice cream shops.
- Community-centric spaces fostered a welcoming atmosphere for locals and visitors alike.
Located at 186 Underhill Ave in Brooklyn, Blue Marble Ice Cream is an upscale ice cream parlor known for its organic flavors made with locally sourced ingredients. This charming spot offers a delightful experience, especially in its outdoor seating area adorned with lights and apple trees.
With a focus on quality, Blue Marble serves a variety of flavors, including vegan options, making it an appealing choice for everyone. The café also offers coffee and pastries, adding to its charm as a community gathering spot.
The café has garnered positive reviews for its friendly staff and quick service, making it a popular destination for both locals and visitors.
Overall, Blue Marble Ice Cream offers a delightful experience for ice cream lovers in Brooklyn.
The café's commitment to quality and community makes it a standout choice.
Whether you're stopping by for a quick treat or enjoying a leisurely afternoon, Blue Marble is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Pros
• High-quality, organic ice cream made with locally sourced ingredients.
• Charming outdoor seating area with lights and apple trees.
• Friendly and attentive staff.
• Offers vegan and dairy-free options.
• Serves coffee and pastries in addition to ice cream.
Cons
• Higher pricing compared to some competitors.
• Occasional concerns about portion sizes.
• Some reports of cleanliness issues.
Ideal for
• Families looking for a sweet treat.
• Friends gathering for a casual outing.
• Anyone enjoying a stroll in Prospect Park.
Things to know before visiting
• Takeout options are available.
• Outdoor seating is popular, especially in warmer months.
• Payment options include credit and debit cards.
Overall impression
Blue Marble Ice Cream stands out for its commitment to quality and community. With a variety of flavors and a welcoming atmosphere, it is a delightful stop for anyone in Prospect Heights.
The combination of organic ingredients, friendly service, and a charming setting makes it a memorable experience.
Whether you're a local or just visiting, Blue Marble Ice Cream is a must-try destination.
Welcome to Blue Marble Ice Cream, a beloved hotspot nestled in the heart of Prospect Heights, Brooklyn. This upscale ice cream parlor is a local treasure, known for its delightful scoops crafted with passion using organic, locally sourced ingredients. Whether you're a Brooklynite, a foodie on the hunt for sustainable treats, or a traveler seeking unique flavors, Blue Marble promises an unforgettable experience.
Blue Marble boasts a variety of organic, small-batch ice cream flavors priced around $2.90 per scoop. From classic favorites to inventive creations like Blue Marble's signature blue vanilla with peanut butter and marshmallow, and intriguing combinations such as rose and bread or black raspberry with chocolate fudge, there is something to excite every palate. Sampling is encouraged, so you can find your perfect scoop before committing.
Pair your ice cream indulgence with freshly brewed coffee from La Colombe, available at a budget-friendly $2.00. The rich, aromatic coffee perfectly complements the sweet, creamy scoops. Feeling peckish? Choose from a selection of assorted pastries, bagels, and other bakery treats at about $2.50 each. Whether it's breakfast, a midday pick-me-up, or dessert, Blue Marble has you covered.
This charming café features a baby blue and white décor that creates a serene ambiance perfect for relaxing or catching up with friends. Outdoor seating beneath twinkling lights and apple trees invites guests to savor their treats while soaking up the vibrant Brooklyn vibe. Friendly and attentive staff enhance the experience by recommending popular flavors and welcoming all visitors warmly.
- Organic ice cream made with locally sourced ingredients, including vegan options.
- Coffee and pastries available for breakfast, lunch, or a sweet treat.
- Outdoor seating under apple trees creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere.
- Accepts modern payment options including debit, credit cards, and NFC payments.
- Family friendly environment suitable for children.
Just a short stroll from Prospect Park, Blue Marble Ice Cream is the ultimate pit stop for those exploring Brooklyn's iconic green space. Whether you're craving a refreshing cone after a jog or a cozy coffee break before your walk, this spot promises quality, sustainability, and a welcoming neighborhood vibe. The combination of innovative ice cream flavors, quality coffee, and a charming setting is why locals and visitors keep coming back.
