Blue Marble Ice Cream menu overview

Discover an enticing selection of organic, small-batch ice cream flavors and treats at Blue Marble Ice Cream, nestled in the heart of Prospect Heights, Brooklyn. This upscale ice cream parlor delights visitors with its locally sourced ingredients and inventive, delicious creations that appeal to both classic tastes and adventurous palates.

Starters - classic and creative ice cream flavors

Begin your Blue Marble experience with their wide variety of ice cream scoops made from fresh cream and sugar, enhanced by natural ingredients. Highlights include the comforting Vanilla with real vanilla bean, the rich Butter Pecan featuring crunchy pecans, and the indulgent Banana Chip blended with chocolate chips and bananas. For a tropical twist, try the Coconut Chocolate Almond, and for mint lovers, the refreshing Mint Chip delivers flecks of mint leaves and chocolate chips.

Cookies - creamy ice cream swirled with cookie bits for a nostalgic crunch.
Grapenut - a classic flavor featuring crunchy grapenuts for texture contrast.
Root Beer - smooth cream infused with root beer extract for a nostalgic soda fountain flavor.
Strawberry - fresh strawberries blended into creamy sweetness for a fruity indulgence.
Chocolate Chip - classic creamy chocolate chip ice cream, a guaranteed crowd-pleaser.
Dulce De Leche - smooth caramel-infused cream for rich and sweet flavor.
Sweet Cream - simple yet luscious cream and sugar base for a pure ice cream experience.
Ginger - aromatic ginger blended with creamy texture for a spicy kick.
Mango Sorbet - vibrant, dairy-free mango sorbet bursting with fresh fruit flavor.
Chocolate - rich cocoa-infused classic chocolate ice cream.
Cinnamon - warm cinnamon spice blended into smooth cream for cozy flavor.

Mains - delightful treats and beverages

Beyond scoops, Blue Marble offers satisfyingly indulgent main dishes and beverages that complement their ice cream menu. The Brownie Sundae layers rich brownie pieces with their creamy ice cream, hot fudge, and fluffy whipped cream for a decadent experience. The Ice Cream Float and Ice Cream Soda bring nostalgic soda fountain vibes with fizzy soda and creamy ice cream harmoniously combined.

Egg Cream - a classic New York drink with milk, seltzer, and chocolate syrup blending smooth and fizzy textures.
Milk Shake - creamy blend of ice cream and milk for a timeless favorite.
Hand Packed Pint - take home your favorite organic ice cream in a convenient pint size.
Bergen Bagels - a simple bagel offering to complement your ice cream experience or coffee break.

Desserts and specials

Blue Marble Ice Cream offers specials that elevate the dessert experience. The Brownie Sundae is a standout, combining decadent brownie chunks with their luscious ice cream, drizzled in hot fudge and crowned with whipped cream. Their innovative Ice Cream Floats deliver a fizzy, creamy sensation that’s perfect for a warm day or a nostalgic treat.

Drinks to accompany your treat

Complement your ice cream indulgence with a variety of carefully crafted drinks. Blue Marble serves a selection of coffee and tea that perfectly balance their sweet offerings. Whether you choose a classic maple latte or an ice-cold nitro cold brew, the drinks menu is designed to satisfy and refresh. Their Egg Cream, a quintessential New York beverage, provides a light and fizzy chocolatey delight, rounding out the Blue Marble experience.

4.2

Ice cream

186 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA

(718) 399-6926

Closed

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

Closed

Wednesday

Closed

Thursday